2
$\begingroup$

In a mass spectrometer some hydrogen chloride molecules will split into atoms. Chlorine has two isotopes. The hydrogen involved here is the isotope $\ce{^1_1H}$ only.

How many peaks does a mass spectrum will show?

My answer was two with $\ce{H^35Cl}$ and $\ce{H^37Cl}$ but I found the answer to be wrong. Where have I been deceived?

I also found the mass spectrum in CIE 9701/02 2003:

Mass spectrum of HCl

Why are there peaks for $m/z = 35$ and $37$? Even if I consider them to be chlorine's, why aren't there any for hydrogen?

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ You missed the very first sentence in your question. $\endgroup$ – orthocresol Sep 10 '17 at 14:17
  • $\begingroup$ I didnt missed it, if thats the situation why isnt there any for hydrogen's? $\endgroup$ – Amar30657 Sep 10 '17 at 14:23
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Oh, right, I didn't understand what your last sentence meant... anyway hydrogen would appear at 1, and your graph is cut off between 0 and 35. $\endgroup$ – orthocresol Sep 10 '17 at 14:44
2
$\begingroup$

Collision between an electron and the molecule during a MS-experiment usually results in two phenomena:

\begin{align} \begin{cases} \ce{AB + e &-> [AB]+ + 2e} &\text{electron ionization}\\ \ce{AB + e &-> [AB]-} &\text{resonance capture} \end{cases} \end{align}

Resonance capture is less frequent and usually doesn't add much to the spectra. For $\ce{HCl}$ considering electron ionization as the primary process the following process takes place:

$$\ce{HCl + e -> [HCl]+ + 2e}$$

Based on ionization method (e.g. applied energy) several fragmentation processes may accompany the formation of cation/cation-radical ($\ce{[HCl]+}$/$\ce{[HCl]^{+.}}$):

\begin{align} \ce{[HCl]+ &-> H+ + Cl^. }\\ \ce{[HCl]+ &-> H^. + Cl+ }\\ \ce{[HCl]+ + e &-> H+ + Cl-} \end{align}

Fragmentation is often followed by recombination acts of different degrees of probability, e.g.: \begin{align} \ce{H+ + Cl- &-> HCl}\\ \ce{H+ + HCl &-> [H2Cl]+}\\ \ce{H^. + [H2Cl]+ &-> [H3Cl]^.+} \end{align}

One can possibly observe peaks of $\ce{[H]+}$ and $\ce{[H2]+}$, but those are usually have negligible intensities due to recombination processes.

Regarding the spectra OP provided, it looks somewhat strange as the base peak @ $m/z = 36$ is not $100\%$ (approx. $90\%$ instead). I would recommend to check for the experimental data in more reliable sources, e.g. in NIST database:

enter image description here

Considering the fragmentation processes and the fact that $\ce{^{35}Cl} : \ce{^{37}Cl} = 3 : 1$, one can perform the following peak assignment:

\begin{array}{rrr} m/z & \text{r.i.}, \% & \text{fragment}\\ \hline 35 & 18 & \ce{[^{35}Cl]+}\\ 36 & 100 & \ce{[^1H^{35}Cl]+}\\ 37 & 6 & \ce{[^{37}Cl]+}\\ 38 & 33 & \ce{[^1H^{37}Cl]+}\\ \hline \end{array}

Alternatively, for $m/z = 37$ and $m/z = 38$ fragments $\ce{[^1H2^{35}Cl]+}$ and $\ce{[^1H3^{35}Cl]+}$, respectively, could be proposed, but it wouldn't be correct due to the following:

  1. recombination acts leading to the formation of large molecules as detected end-products are less possible and usually result in much smaller peaks;
  2. observed relative intensities are not in agreement with isotope distribution for chlorine ($\ce{^{35}Cl} : \ce{^{37}Cl} = 3 : 1$, which is in agreement with r.i. ratios for $\ce{[^{35}Cl]+} : \ce{[^{37}Cl]+} = 18 : 6$ and $\ce{[^1H^{35}Cl]+} : \ce{[^1H^{37}Cl]+} = 100 : 33$, but not with alternatively proposed fragments);
  3. the problem itself states that

    hydrogen chloride molecules will split into atoms.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.