I have a titration of Calcium Ions with EDTA. When I reach a volume of 9.6mL I the liquid turns slightly blue and after that the more I add the bluer it becomes. Now at what point is my titration finished? When I notice the first change or as soon as adding more EDTA doesnt change the color?
Assuming you've used Erichrome Black-T as an indicator, the second your whole solution changes from wine red to blue, as in the moment you realise there is a change in colour, however light it is, that's your end point and you should stop.
Make sure you use a white tile under your conical flask and remember to pause the titration and swirl the flask little bit every now and then as you near the end point. That should even out the colour and make the change noticeable before it's too late.