Skip to main content
slight clean up
Source Link
Gaurang Tandon
  • 9.9k
  • 12
  • 67
  • 126

Specific Rotation:Why are Why is the valuesvalue of specific rotation different in different cases?

An unknown compound with a mass of $4.5~\mathrm{g}$ is dissolved in enough carbon tetrachloride to make a total volume of $250~\mathrm{cm^3}$. The observed rotation of this solution is $+357.75^\circ$ in a $25~\mathrm{cm}$ cell using the sodium D line. But if $4.5~\mathrm{g}$ is dissolved in $125~\mathrm{cm^3}$ we observed rotation is $+355.50^\circ$. Calculate specific rotation for this compound. (assuming length of polarimeter tube is $1~\mathrm{dm}$)

My approach is starting with the formula stated on Wikipedia.

$$\text{Specific Rotation (in first case)} = \frac{+357.75^\circ}{\left(\frac{4.5}{250}\right)(1)}=19875^\circ=75^\circ$$$$\text{Specific rotation (in first case)} = \frac{+357.75^\circ}{\left(\frac{4.5}{250}\right)(1)}=19875^\circ=75^\circ$$

$$\text{Specific Rotation (in second case)} = \frac{+355.50^\circ}{\left(\frac{4.5}{125}\right)(1)}=9875^\circ=155^\circ$$$$\text{Specific rotation (in second case)} = \frac{+355.50^\circ}{\left(\frac{4.5}{125}\right)(1)}=9875^\circ=155^\circ$$

Any idea why the two answers are different? Did I miss out something?

Specific Rotation:Why are the values different in different cases?

An unknown compound with a mass of $4.5~\mathrm{g}$ is dissolved in enough carbon tetrachloride to make a total volume of $250~\mathrm{cm^3}$. The observed rotation of this solution is $+357.75^\circ$ in a $25~\mathrm{cm}$ cell using the sodium D line. But if $4.5~\mathrm{g}$ is dissolved in $125~\mathrm{cm^3}$ we observed rotation is $+355.50^\circ$. Calculate specific rotation for this compound. (assuming length of polarimeter tube is $1~\mathrm{dm}$)

My approach is starting with the formula stated on Wikipedia.

$$\text{Specific Rotation (in first case)} = \frac{+357.75^\circ}{\left(\frac{4.5}{250}\right)(1)}=19875^\circ=75^\circ$$

$$\text{Specific Rotation (in second case)} = \frac{+355.50^\circ}{\left(\frac{4.5}{125}\right)(1)}=9875^\circ=155^\circ$$

Any idea why the two answers are different? Did I miss out something?

Why is the value of specific rotation different in different cases?

An unknown compound with a mass of $4.5~\mathrm{g}$ is dissolved in enough carbon tetrachloride to make a total volume of $250~\mathrm{cm^3}$. The observed rotation of this solution is $+357.75^\circ$ in a $25~\mathrm{cm}$ cell using the sodium D line. But if $4.5~\mathrm{g}$ is dissolved in $125~\mathrm{cm^3}$ we observed rotation is $+355.50^\circ$. Calculate specific rotation for this compound. (assuming length of polarimeter tube is $1~\mathrm{dm}$)

My approach is starting with the formula stated on Wikipedia.

$$\text{Specific rotation (in first case)} = \frac{+357.75^\circ}{\left(\frac{4.5}{250}\right)(1)}=19875^\circ=75^\circ$$

$$\text{Specific rotation (in second case)} = \frac{+355.50^\circ}{\left(\frac{4.5}{125}\right)(1)}=9875^\circ=155^\circ$$

Any idea why the two answers are different? Did I miss out something?

corrected MathJax
Source Link

An unknown compound weighingwith a mass of $4.5$ gm$4.5~\mathrm{g}$ is dissolved in enough carbon tetrachloride tetrachloride to make a total volume of $250$ c.c$250~\mathrm{cm^3}$. The observed rotation rotation of this solution is $+357.75°$$+357.75^\circ$ in a $25$ cm$25~\mathrm{cm}$ cell using the sodium sodium D line. But if $4.5$ gm$4.5~\mathrm{g}$ is dissolved in $125$ cc$125~\mathrm{cm^3}$ we observed rotation rotation is $+355.50°$$+355.50^\circ$. Calculate specific rotation for this compound.    (assuming length of polarimeter tube is $1$ dm$1~\mathrm{dm}$)

MY APPROACH: UsingMy approach is starting with the formula stated hereon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specific_rotation#For_solutionsWikipedia.

Specific Rotation (in first case)=$$\frac{+357.75^{0}}{(\frac{4.5}{250})(1)}=19875^{0}=75^{0}$$$$\text{Specific Rotation (in first case)} = \frac{+357.75^\circ}{\left(\frac{4.5}{250}\right)(1)}=19875^\circ=75^\circ$$

Specific Rotation (in second case)=$$\frac{+355.50^{0}}{(\frac{4.5}{125})(1)}=9875^{0}=155^{0}$$$$\text{Specific Rotation (in second case)} = \frac{+355.50^\circ}{\left(\frac{4.5}{125}\right)(1)}=9875^\circ=155^\circ$$

Any idea why the two answers are different?Did Did I miss out something?

An unknown compound weighing $4.5$ gm is dissolved in enough carbon tetrachloride to make a total volume of $250$ c.c. The observed rotation of this solution is $+357.75°$ in a $25$ cm cell using the sodium D line. But if $4.5$ gm is dissolved in $125$ cc we observed rotation is $+355.50°$. Calculate specific rotation for this compound.  (assuming length of polarimeter tube is $1$ dm)

MY APPROACH: Using the formula stated here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specific_rotation#For_solutions

Specific Rotation (in first case)=$$\frac{+357.75^{0}}{(\frac{4.5}{250})(1)}=19875^{0}=75^{0}$$

Specific Rotation (in second case)=$$\frac{+355.50^{0}}{(\frac{4.5}{125})(1)}=9875^{0}=155^{0}$$

Any idea why the two answers are different?Did I miss out something?

An unknown compound with a mass of $4.5~\mathrm{g}$ is dissolved in enough carbon tetrachloride to make a total volume of $250~\mathrm{cm^3}$. The observed rotation of this solution is $+357.75^\circ$ in a $25~\mathrm{cm}$ cell using the sodium D line. But if $4.5~\mathrm{g}$ is dissolved in $125~\mathrm{cm^3}$ we observed rotation is $+355.50^\circ$. Calculate specific rotation for this compound.  (assuming length of polarimeter tube is $1~\mathrm{dm}$)

My approach is starting with the formula stated on Wikipedia.

$$\text{Specific Rotation (in first case)} = \frac{+357.75^\circ}{\left(\frac{4.5}{250}\right)(1)}=19875^\circ=75^\circ$$

$$\text{Specific Rotation (in second case)} = \frac{+355.50^\circ}{\left(\frac{4.5}{125}\right)(1)}=9875^\circ=155^\circ$$

Any idea why the two answers are different? Did I miss out something?

Tweeted twitter.com/StackChemistry/status/779197814773547008
deleted 1 character in body
Source Link
user14857
user14857

An unknown compound weighing $4.5$ gm is dissolved in enough carbon tetrachloride to make a total volume of $250$ c.c. The observed rotation of this solution is $+357.75°$ in a $25$ cm cell using the sodium D line. But if $4.5$ gm is dissolved in $125$ cc we observed rotation is $+355.50°$. Calculate specific rotation for this compound. (assuming length of polarimeter tube is $1$ dm)

MY APPROACH: Using the formula stated here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specific_rotation#For_solutions

Specific Rotation (in first case)=$$\frac{+357.75^{0}}{(\frac{4.5}{250})(2.5)}=7950^{0}=30^{0}$$$$\frac{+357.75^{0}}{(\frac{4.5}{250})(1)}=19875^{0}=75^{0}$$

Specific Rotation (in second case)=$$\frac{+355.50^{0}}{(\frac{4.5}{125})(1)}=9875^{0}=155^{0}$$

Any idea why the two answers are different?Did I miss out something?

An unknown compound weighing $4.5$ gm is dissolved in enough carbon tetrachloride to make a total volume of $250$ c.c. The observed rotation of this solution is $+357.75°$ in a $25$ cm cell using the sodium D line. But if $4.5$ gm is dissolved in $125$ cc we observed rotation is $+355.50°$. Calculate specific rotation for this compound. (assuming length of polarimeter tube is $1$ dm)

MY APPROACH: Using the formula stated here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specific_rotation#For_solutions

Specific Rotation (in first case)=$$\frac{+357.75^{0}}{(\frac{4.5}{250})(2.5)}=7950^{0}=30^{0}$$

Specific Rotation (in second case)=$$\frac{+355.50^{0}}{(\frac{4.5}{125})(1)}=9875^{0}=155^{0}$$

Any idea why the two answers are different?Did I miss out something?

An unknown compound weighing $4.5$ gm is dissolved in enough carbon tetrachloride to make a total volume of $250$ c.c. The observed rotation of this solution is $+357.75°$ in a $25$ cm cell using the sodium D line. But if $4.5$ gm is dissolved in $125$ cc we observed rotation is $+355.50°$. Calculate specific rotation for this compound. (assuming length of polarimeter tube is $1$ dm)

MY APPROACH: Using the formula stated here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specific_rotation#For_solutions

Specific Rotation (in first case)=$$\frac{+357.75^{0}}{(\frac{4.5}{250})(1)}=19875^{0}=75^{0}$$

Specific Rotation (in second case)=$$\frac{+355.50^{0}}{(\frac{4.5}{125})(1)}=9875^{0}=155^{0}$$

Any idea why the two answers are different?Did I miss out something?

Source Link
user14857
user14857
Loading