Skip to main content

A little chemical detective work gives a plausible answer.

Say the metal is cobalt and it's oxidation state is +2. Then, with the cobalt calcined to the oxide, you have two possible acid-base reactions:

$\ce{CoO + 2 NaBO2 => Co(BO2)2 + Na2O}$$\ce{CoO + 2 NaBO2 -> Co(BO2)2 + Na2O}$

$\ce{CoO + B2O3 => Co(BO2)2}$$\ce{CoO + B2O3 -> Co(BO2)2}$

Both reactions look good, but upon further review the first one gives something we recognize as a powerful base, more likely to be a reactant than a product. Moreover, a quick check here reveals that boric oxide has a low enough melting point to liquefy in the flame, favoring the second reaction kinetic-ally (hyphen put in because device autocorrect is acting badly)kinetically.

So the second reaction above is really the only plausible one.

A little chemical detective work gives a plausible answer.

Say the metal is cobalt and it's oxidation state is +2. Then, with the cobalt calcined to the oxide, you have two possible acid-base reactions:

$\ce{CoO + 2 NaBO2 => Co(BO2)2 + Na2O}$

$\ce{CoO + B2O3 => Co(BO2)2}$

Both reactions look good, but upon further review the first one gives something we recognize as a powerful base, more likely to be a reactant than a product. Moreover, a quick check here reveals that boric oxide has a low enough melting point to liquefy in the flame, favoring the second reaction kinetic-ally (hyphen put in because device autocorrect is acting badly).

So the second reaction above is really the only plausible one.

A little chemical detective work gives a plausible answer.

Say the metal is cobalt and it's oxidation state is +2. Then, with the cobalt calcined to the oxide, you have two possible acid-base reactions:

$\ce{CoO + 2 NaBO2 -> Co(BO2)2 + Na2O}$

$\ce{CoO + B2O3 -> Co(BO2)2}$

Both reactions look good, but upon further review the first one gives something we recognize as a powerful base, more likely to be a reactant than a product. Moreover, a quick check here reveals that boric oxide has a low enough melting point to liquefy in the flame, favoring the second reaction kinetically.

So the second reaction above is really the only plausible one.

Source Link
Oscar Lanzi
  • 62.6k
  • 4
  • 96
  • 187

A little chemical detective work gives a plausible answer.

Say the metal is cobalt and it's oxidation state is +2. Then, with the cobalt calcined to the oxide, you have two possible acid-base reactions:

$\ce{CoO + 2 NaBO2 => Co(BO2)2 + Na2O}$

$\ce{CoO + B2O3 => Co(BO2)2}$

Both reactions look good, but upon further review the first one gives something we recognize as a powerful base, more likely to be a reactant than a product. Moreover, a quick check here reveals that boric oxide has a low enough melting point to liquefy in the flame, favoring the second reaction kinetic-ally (hyphen put in because device autocorrect is acting badly).

So the second reaction above is really the only plausible one.