Return to Answer

Schottky defect occurs when equal number of positive and negative ions are missing from the lattice thereby maintaining net electrical neautrality and leading to a decreased density in the lattice (since there are now less number of ions) . It is observed to be occurring in cations and anions of similar sizes. NOW CONSIDER THAT AN ION IS AT THE LATTICE POSITION AND A DEFECT IS TO BE OCCURRED. There are 2 ways stoichiometric conditions can be satisfied. - either by loosing this ion as well as another of opposite charge in equal ratio(SCHOTTKY) , OR not losing this ion at all , but just shifting it's position from lattice position to interstitial one.(FRENKEL)---- If we think logically , Since it's a stoichiometric defect it should maintain neautrality as well as loose cations and anions in a certain ratio. If the sizes were very different , there are chances the smaller ion would occupy an interstitial space causing it to create a hole and still maintain neutrality and ratio without losing any ions. (Which is what happens in Frenkel defect) . Since however ions are of similar sizes , one can't occupy an interstitial space .. and therefore losing equal no. Of anions and cations is the only way to go. You can think of these as 2 cases of defect... Yes it's not necessary the ions are of similar sizes for a defect to occur BUT IF THEY ARE...They are most likely to cause the Schottky defect and if not , then Frenkel Defect. As for your NaCl doubt , I would suggest try finding the critical radius ratio for one ion to occupy the interstitial space . This way you can verify whether it can perform Frenkel defect or not ..Or why it's performing Schottky. Hope this helps. EDIT:- I can't find any examples of ${\ce{AB2}} $ type as such , but you can again try finding critical ratio of ions in ${\ce{AB2}} $ lattices to decide what type of defect they are likely to occur.

Schottky defect occurs when equal number of positive and negative ions are missing from the lattice thereby maintaining net electrical neautrality and leading to a decreased density in the lattice (since there are now less number of ions) . It is observed to be occurring in cations and anions of similar sizes.

NOW CONSIDER THAT AN ION IS AT THE LATTICE POSITION AND A DEFECT IS TO BE OCCURRED.

There are 2 ways stoichiometric conditions can be satisfied. - either by loosing this ion as well as another of opposite charge in equal ratio(SCHOTTKY) , OR not losing this ion at all , but just shifting it's position from lattice position to interstitial one.(FRENKEL)---- If we think logically ,

Since it's a stoichiometric defect it should maintain neautrality as well as loose cations and anions in a certain ratio.

If the sizes were very different , there are chances the smaller ion would occupy an interstitial space causing it to create a hole and still maintain neutrality and ratio without losing any ions. (Which is what happens in Frenkel defect) . Since however ions are of similar sizes , one can't occupy an interstitial space .. and therefore losing equal no. Of anions and cations is the only way to go. You can think of these as 2 cases of defect... Yes it's not necessary the ions are of similar sizes for a defect to occur BUT IF THEY ARE...They are most likely to cause the Schottky defect and if not , then Frenkel Defect. As for your NaCl doubt , I would suggest try finding the critical radius ratio for one ion to occupy the interstitial space . This way you can verify whether it can perform Frenkel defect or not ..Or why it's performing Schottky. Hope this helps.

EDIT:- I can't find any examples of ${\ce{AB2}} $ type as such , but you can again try finding critical ratio of ions in ${\ce{AB2}} $ lattices to decide what type of defect they are likely to occur.

Schottky defect occurs when equal number of positive and negative ions are missing from the lattice thereby maintaining net electrical neautrality and leading to a decreased density in the lattice (since there are now less number of ions) . It is observed to be occurring in cations and anions of similar sizes. NOW CONSIDER THAT AN ION IS AT THE LATTICE POSITION AND A DEFECT IS TO BE OCCURRED. There are 2 ways stoichiometric conditions can be satisfied. - either by loosing this ion as well as another of opposite charge in equal ratio(SCHOTTKY) , OR not losing this ion at all , but just shifting it's position from lattice position to interstitial one.(FRENKEL)---- If we think logically , Since it's a stoichiometric defect it should maintain neautrality as well as loose cations and anions in a certain ratio. If the sizes were very different , there are chances the smaller ion would occupy an interstitial space causing it to create a hole and still maintain neutrality and ratio without losing any ions. (Which is wat happens in Frenkel defect) . Since however ions are of similar sizes , one can't occupy an interstitial space .. and therefore losing equal no. Of anions and cations is the only way to go. You can think of these as 2 cases of defect... Yes it's not necessary the ions are of similar sizes for a defect to occur BUT IF THEY ARE...They are most likely to cause the Schottky defect and if not , then Frenkel Defect. As for your NaCl doubt , I would suggest try finding the critical radius ratio for one ion to occupy the interstitial space . This way you can verify whether it can perform Frenkel defect or not ..Or why it's performing Schottky. Hope this helps. EDIT:- I can't find any examples of AB2 type as such , but you can again try finding critical ratio of ions in AB2 lattices to decide what type of defect they are likely to occur.

Schottky defect occurs when equal number of positive and negative ions are missing from the lattice thereby maintaining net electrical neautrality and leading to a decreased density in the lattice (since there are now less number of ions) . It is observed to be occurring in cations and anions of similar sizes. NOW CONSIDER THAT AN ION IS AT THE LATTICE POSITION AND A DEFECT IS TO BE OCCURRED. There are 2 ways stoichiometric conditions can be satisfied. - either by loosing this ion as well as another of opposite charge in equal ratio(SCHOTTKY) , OR not losing this ion at all , but just shifting it's position from lattice position to interstitial one.(FRENKEL)---- If we think logically , Since it's a stoichiometric defect it should maintain neautrality as well as loose cations and anions in a certain ratio. If the sizes were very different , there are chances the smaller ion would occupy an interstitial space causing it to create a hole and still maintain neutrality and ratio without losing any ions. (Which is what happens in Frenkel defect) . Since however ions are of similar sizes , one can't occupy an interstitial space .. and therefore losing equal no. Of anions and cations is the only way to go. You can think of these as 2 cases of defect... Yes it's not necessary the ions are of similar sizes for a defect to occur BUT IF THEY ARE...They are most likely to cause the Schottky defect and if not , then Frenkel Defect. As for your NaCl doubt , I would suggest try finding the critical radius ratio for one ion to occupy the interstitial space . This way you can verify whether it can perform Frenkel defect or not ..Or why it's performing Schottky. Hope this helps. EDIT:- I can't find any examples of ${\ce{AB2}} $ type as such , but you can again try finding critical ratio of ions in ${\ce{AB2}} $ lattices to decide what type of defect they are likely to occur.

Schottky defect occurs when equal number of positive and negative ions are missing from the lattice thereby maintaining net electrical neautrality and leading to a decreased density in the lattice (since there are now less number of ions) . It is observed to be occurring in cations and anions of similar sizes. If we think logically , Since it's a stoichiometric defect it should maintain neautrality as well as loose cations and anions in a certain ratio. If the sizes were very different , there are chances the smaller ion would occupy an interstitial space causing it to create a hole and still maintain neutrality and ratio without losing any ions. (Which is wat happens in Frenkel defect) . Since however ions are of similar sizes , one can't occupy an interstitial space .. and therefore losing equal no. Of anions and cations is the only way to go. You can think of these as 2 cases of defect... Yes it's not necessary the ions are of similar sizes for a defect to occur BUT IF THEY ARE...They are most likely to cause the Schottky defect and if not , then Frenkel Defect. As for your NaCl doubt , I would suggest try finding the critical radius ratio for one ion to occupy the interstitial space . This way you can verify whether it can perform Frenkel defect or not ..Or why it's performing Schottky. Hope this helps.

Schottky defect occurs when equal number of positive and negative ions are missing from the lattice thereby maintaining net electrical neautrality and leading to a decreased density in the lattice (since there are now less number of ions) . It is observed to be occurring in cations and anions of similar sizes. NOW CONSIDER THAT AN ION IS AT THE LATTICE POSITION AND A DEFECT IS TO BE OCCURRED. There are 2 ways stoichiometric conditions can be satisfied. - either by loosing this ion as well as another of opposite charge in equal ratio(SCHOTTKY) , OR not losing this ion at all , but just shifting it's position from lattice position to interstitial one.(FRENKEL)---- If we think logically , Since it's a stoichiometric defect it should maintain neautrality as well as loose cations and anions in a certain ratio. If the sizes were very different , there are chances the smaller ion would occupy an interstitial space causing it to create a hole and still maintain neutrality and ratio without losing any ions. (Which is wat happens in Frenkel defect) . Since however ions are of similar sizes , one can't occupy an interstitial space .. and therefore losing equal no. Of anions and cations is the only way to go. You can think of these as 2 cases of defect... Yes it's not necessary the ions are of similar sizes for a defect to occur BUT IF THEY ARE...They are most likely to cause the Schottky defect and if not , then Frenkel Defect. As for your NaCl doubt , I would suggest try finding the critical radius ratio for one ion to occupy the interstitial space . This way you can verify whether it can perform Frenkel defect or not ..Or why it's performing Schottky. Hope this helps. EDIT:- I can't find any examples of AB2 type as such , but you can again try finding critical ratio of ions in AB2 lattices to decide what type of defect they are likely to occur.