Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/StackChemistry/status/1179365451392008197
Became Hot Network Question
OCRed photo with MathJax; corrected notations (sec is wrong and shouldn't be used for seconds; fwd and rev indices are commonly used in kinetics to avoid confusion with f (fusion))
Source Link
andselisk
  • 38.5k
  • 14
  • 133
  • 223

Consider a reversible reaction $\ce{A}$ converts to $\ce{B}$ and $\ce{B}$ converts to $\ce{A}$ with forward and backward rate constants $k_\mathrm{fwd} = k_\mathrm{rev }= \pu{1 s-1}.$ Suppose we start with a 1 molar solution of $\ce{A}$. How long will the concentration of $\ce{A}$ take to reach 0.75 molar?

Consider a reversible reaction A converts to B and B converts to A with forward and backward rate constants Kf=Kb= 1sec raised to the power minus 1. Suppose we start with a 1 molar solution of A. How long will the concentration of A take to reach 0.75 molar? Here's what I have done:

$$\ce{A <=>[$k_\mathrm{fwd}$][$k_\mathrm{rev}$] B}$$

$$k_\mathrm{fwd} = k_\mathrm{rev} = \pu{1 s-1}$$

$$-\frac{\mathrm d[\ce{A}]}{\mathrm dt} = k_\mathrm{fwd}[\ce{A}]^n - k_\mathrm{rev}[\ce{B}]^m$$

For the first order reaction -$n = m =1$:

enter image description here$$ \begin{align} \frac{\mathrm d[\ce{A}]}{\mathrm dt} &= k_\mathrm{rev}[\ce{B}] - k_\mathrm{fwd}[\ce{A}] \\ &= k_\mathrm{rev}([\ce{A}]_0 - [\ce{A}]) - k_\mathrm{fwd}[\ce{A}] &\qquad \{[\ce{B}] = [\ce{A}]_0 - [\ce{A}]\} \\ &= k_\mathrm{rev}[\ce{A}]_0 - k_\mathrm{rev}[\ce{A}] - k_\mathrm{fwd}[\ce{A}] \\ &= k_\mathrm{rev}[\ce{A}]_0 - [\ce{A}](k_\mathrm{rev} + k_\mathrm{fwd}) \\ &= [\ce{A}]_0 -2[\ce{A}] &\qquad \{k_\mathrm{rev} = k_\mathrm{fwd} = 1\} \end{align} $$

$$\frac{\mathrm d[\ce{A}]}{\mathrm dt} = [\ce{A}]_0 -2[\ce{A}]$$

$$\int_{[\ce{A}]_0}^{[\ce{A}]_t}\frac{\mathrm d[\ce{A}]}{[\ce{A}]_0 - 2[\ce{A}]} = \int_0^t\mathrm dt$$

$$\frac 1 2 \ln{\left(\frac{0.5 - 0.75}{0.5 - 1}\right)} = t$$

$$t = \pu{-0.35 s}$$

My answer is coming in negative. I am a biology student and not good at calculus  . Is something wrong with the mathsmath or the whole process is wrong .?

Consider a reversible reaction A converts to B and B converts to A with forward and backward rate constants Kf=Kb= 1sec raised to the power minus 1. Suppose we start with a 1 molar solution of A. How long will the concentration of A take to reach 0.75 molar? Here's what I have done: -

enter image description here

My answer is coming in negative. I am a biology student and not good at calculus  . Is something wrong with the maths or the whole process is wrong .

Consider a reversible reaction $\ce{A}$ converts to $\ce{B}$ and $\ce{B}$ converts to $\ce{A}$ with forward and backward rate constants $k_\mathrm{fwd} = k_\mathrm{rev }= \pu{1 s-1}.$ Suppose we start with a 1 molar solution of $\ce{A}$. How long will the concentration of $\ce{A}$ take to reach 0.75 molar?

Here's what I have done:

$$\ce{A <=>[$k_\mathrm{fwd}$][$k_\mathrm{rev}$] B}$$

$$k_\mathrm{fwd} = k_\mathrm{rev} = \pu{1 s-1}$$

$$-\frac{\mathrm d[\ce{A}]}{\mathrm dt} = k_\mathrm{fwd}[\ce{A}]^n - k_\mathrm{rev}[\ce{B}]^m$$

For the first order reaction $n = m =1$:

$$ \begin{align} \frac{\mathrm d[\ce{A}]}{\mathrm dt} &= k_\mathrm{rev}[\ce{B}] - k_\mathrm{fwd}[\ce{A}] \\ &= k_\mathrm{rev}([\ce{A}]_0 - [\ce{A}]) - k_\mathrm{fwd}[\ce{A}] &\qquad \{[\ce{B}] = [\ce{A}]_0 - [\ce{A}]\} \\ &= k_\mathrm{rev}[\ce{A}]_0 - k_\mathrm{rev}[\ce{A}] - k_\mathrm{fwd}[\ce{A}] \\ &= k_\mathrm{rev}[\ce{A}]_0 - [\ce{A}](k_\mathrm{rev} + k_\mathrm{fwd}) \\ &= [\ce{A}]_0 -2[\ce{A}] &\qquad \{k_\mathrm{rev} = k_\mathrm{fwd} = 1\} \end{align} $$

$$\frac{\mathrm d[\ce{A}]}{\mathrm dt} = [\ce{A}]_0 -2[\ce{A}]$$

$$\int_{[\ce{A}]_0}^{[\ce{A}]_t}\frac{\mathrm d[\ce{A}]}{[\ce{A}]_0 - 2[\ce{A}]} = \int_0^t\mathrm dt$$

$$\frac 1 2 \ln{\left(\frac{0.5 - 0.75}{0.5 - 1}\right)} = t$$

$$t = \pu{-0.35 s}$$

My answer is coming in negative. I am a biology student and not good at calculus. Is something wrong with the math or the whole process is wrong?

Source Link

Chemical kinetics

Consider a reversible reaction A converts to B and B converts to A with forward and backward rate constants Kf=Kb= 1sec raised to the power minus 1. Suppose we start with a 1 molar solution of A. How long will the concentration of A take to reach 0.75 molar? Here's what I have done: -

enter image description here

My answer is coming in negative. I am a biology student and not good at calculus . Is something wrong with the maths or the whole process is wrong .