0
$\begingroup$

Is it possible to say whether or not a system A or B has stronger intermolecular forces from a phase diagram according to which:

  1. The $T_{\text{b}}$ of A is lower than the $T_{\text{b}}$ of B.
  2. The $T_{\text{melting}}$ of A is higher than the $T_{\text{m}}$ of B.
  3. The triple points of A and B are the same.

Or is it not possible to compare A and B's intermolecular forces from a phase diagram?

I was sure that B has stronger intermolecular forces, as its boiling point is higher than for A at the same pressure.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

This is an interesting situation. It would be easier to answer if the mp and bp of A were both either higher or lower than for B.

But your measure of the strength of intermolecular forces will be melting point - and boiling point. And they give different answers, so how do we make a decision?

Consider the boiling point first: the higher boiling point of B suggests higher intermolecular forces, as you have concluded. Heat of vaporization is needed to put a molecule into the vapor phase, and it seems that B needs more energy to go gaseous.

But A melts at a higher temperature, suggesting that its molecules are held together in a solid phase by stronger bonds. Solid A needs more energy to turn it into a liquid; perhaps A can pack into a tighter solid structure. It would then need more heat to melt it, so it has a larger heat of fusion.

Then your answer must have two parts: A is more tightly bound in a solid framework, but after you put enough heat into both A and B to melt them, B has more intermolecular bonding capacity as a liquid than A does. So B boils higher and is more strongly bound as a liquid.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ James, first of all thank you for your answer. Though I'm still not sure how to answer this question. Do you think it would be appropriate to say, that as A and B are in different states of matter, therefore it's impossible to compare their intermolecular forces? $\endgroup$ – Daniella Jun 14 '18 at 15:51
  • $\begingroup$ Rather, melting and boiling are two different types of strength measurements; each has a heat required, and they are not necessarily related. So you can compare one set of heats (fusion) and decide which of A or B has stronger bonds. Then you compare the heats of evaporation and decide which of A or B seems to show stronger intermolecular strength at the higher temperature. Perhaps strength is a concept that you can measure by the amount of heat required to "break". $\endgroup$ – James Gaidis Jun 15 '18 at 13:32

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.