For which pair of species is the difference in radii the greatest?

(A) $\ce{Li}$ and $\ce{F}$

(B) $\ce{Li+}$ and $\ce{F^-}$

(C) $\ce{Li+}$ and $\ce{O^2-}$

(D) $\ce{O^2-}$ and $\ce{F^-}$

I am pretty sure it is not (D) as $\ce{O^2-}$ and $\ce{F^-}$ are quite close to each other on the periodic table and should have atomic radii pretty much the same.

I also know that gaining an electron increases the atomic radii whereas losing one decreases atomic radius. Also, as you move to the right of the periodic table atomic radius decreases.

I would think that the answer would be (A) because Li is larger than F, and the other choices result in Li becoming smaller and F becoming larger which decreases the difference in radii, but this is not the correct answer (which is C). Can someone please explain?


Your argument that $r_{Li}>r_{F}$ is valid only for the neutral atoms.Consider the lithium ion. Its electronic configuration is exactly similar to helium but the nuclear charge is greater by one unit, and hence is even smaller than the helium atom. On gaining an electron, fluorine now has the electronic configuration of neon with lesser nuclear charge and hence is larger than a neon atom. Similar, oxide ion, with even lesser nuclear charge is the largest. The decrease in radius of lithium on losing one electron (reduction by one entire shell), more than compensates for the difference in the radii of neutral lithium and fluorine. Finally, the order appears to be:-

$$\ce{Li+ < He < F < Li < F- < O^{2-} }$$


Think carefully about it. What is the charge of the NUCLEUS of oxygen compared to the charge of the NUCLEUS of fluorine? Next, what happens when the charge difference (between a positive and negative object) is smaller or larger? Also, for your favorite atom, find how far an electron would have to be if the nucleus were of the size of a golf ball or pinball. Is the size (hint: not the charge) of the nucleus more significant or is how far the farthest electron is found more significant in detemining the size of an atom?


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.