I am asked to identify the "best catalyst" for the reaction:


The options are (A) benzyl chloride (B) aniline (C) N,N,N-trimethylbenzylamine chloride, and (D) N-phenylethanamide.

Now, at first, I immediately thought that the catalyst chosen may have to prevent a possible ring formation, given there are already ten carbon atoms. However, I am not sure how any of those catalysts help prevent that (I doubt if a ring would even form though, because there isn't any nucleophile, but those ten carbons look suspicious!)

Anyway, I realized that this catalyst may have to be polar aprotic for the given SN2 to occur. But, all of the given catalysts are pretty protic (resonance delocalisation of the benzyl carbanion with the ring) I would rank them on proticity as (D) > (C) > (B) > (A).

Hence, although all are protic, I may make a vague guess that (A) is the least protic and hence the answer. However, the answer given is (C) and the solution instead states that:

Solvation of nucleophile is very less in presence of quaternary ammonium salt.

So, how? Where did the part about acidity go? And why worry about solvation? There doesn't appear to be any factor related to it at all (I read from here). Even so, how exactly would quaternary ammonium salts be poorer "solvators" than the others, say option (A)? Can I even predict this theoretically?

Source: MS Chouhan; Advanced Problems In Organic Chemistry; 11th ed; Q11 in Amines


Trimethylbenzylammonium chloride is in this reaction a good example of a phase transfer catalyst. It first forms the trimethylbenzylammonium cyanide in aqueous phase (or on the surface of solid phase) which is soluble in the organic phase. Because of the polar nature of the cyanide ion it is not going to be heavily solvated by organic solvent (in this case benzene) molecules so the result is 'naked' cyanide which is highly reactive. This reacts with the substrate forming, in this case, the cyanodecane and trimethylbenzylammonium bromide. The trimethylbenzylammonium bromide is then free to migrate back to the aqueous phase and exchange anion to reform trimethylbenzylammonium cyanide. Most phase transfer reactions benefit from vigorous stirring to accelerate the exchange between the phases.

Further reading in this PDF.

  • $\begingroup$ Interesting, thanks for your answer! Can you comment on why the other options are not good examples of phase transfer catalysts? Is it possible to compare this property theoretically? Also, which page was I supposed to read in that PDF? $\endgroup$ – Gaurang Tandon Mar 17 '18 at 2:37
  • $\begingroup$ Benzyl Chloride - not good as it is an alternative substrate for the nucleophile. Aniline and phenylethanamide - not good as it is not soluble in aq. phase or able to draw cyanide ions into solution from solid phase. Section 1.2.3 of the PDF mentions the concept of the 'naked' ion. I am not aware of any theoretical model to predict PT catalytic property - this does not mean it does not exist $\endgroup$ – Waylander Mar 17 '18 at 8:40

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.