The following reaction follows the $S_N2$ pathway: $$\ce{CH3CH2CH2-Br + I- (presence of DMSO) -> CH3CH2CH2I + Br-}$$ I found this reaction in my textbook and according to me this reaction should not even take place. $\ce{Br-}$ is a stronger base than $\ce{I-}$ and keeping in mind, stronger the base, lesser is the leaving ability, why will $\ce{I-}$ replace $\ce{Br-}$ in the first place?


2 Answers 2


As you suggest "$\ce{Br−}$ is a stronger base than $\ce{I−}$ and keeping in mind, stronger the base, lesser is the leavability, $\ce{I−}$ should not replace $\ce{Br−}$ "

I actually agree with the logic and according to me, infact, the reverse reaction, i.e.

$$\ce{CH3CH2CH2I + Br- (presence of DMSO) -> CH3CH2CH2Br + I-}$$

should be much more favourable. Because we already know, that in the aprotic solvents, the nucleophilicity of halides is $\ce{F− > Cl− > Br− > I−}$, so $\ce{I−}$ should be a better leaving group and $\ce{Br−}$ should be a better nucleophile .


This reaction would be similar to Finkelstein reaction. Here instead of using acetone, you are using $\ce{NaI}$ in DMSO.

We usually use $\ce{R-Cl}$ in a non polar solvent in Finkelstein reaction, not only for increasing nucleophilicty of the attacking reagent, but also to precipitate the $\ce{NaCl}$ formed in the reaction.

The increasing order of solubility in non polar solvent for sodium halides is: $\ce{NaF < NaCl < NaBr < NaI}$

The order is similar for potassium halides. This order is due to polarisation. In non polar solvents, $\ce{KI}$ is soluble but $\ce{KCl}$ is not. This drives the reaction forward to completeness.

The difference in solubility in $\ce{NaI}$ and $\ce{NaBr}$ (or the potassium derivatives) is not very appreciable, so the reaction will take place in the forward direction, but will not give a very good percentage yield of product.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.