18
$\begingroup$

Recently we had this challenge in our Organic Chemistry Department. I was not involved in it but I thought it might be interesting for the SE Chemistry site, so here it is.

Propose a structure for C20H18 with the longest IUPAC name. Following rules apply:

  1. Names must be generated with MarvinSketch: Structure>Generate Name…>Preferred IUPAC Name (https://www.chemaxon.com/products/marvin).
  2. No isotopic markings can be used.
  3. The structures must be possible (no cycles with too much unsaturations nor systems with impossible tension).
  4. All the characters will be counted: numbers, letters, points, colons, dashes, everything.
  5. Longest name wins.

Here is the example that was given:

enter image description here

and the name provided by MarvinSketch:

(1'R,4'Z,6'Z,8'Z,10'Z,12'S,15'R,16'R,17'R)-spiro[cyclopropane-1,18'-tetracyclo[13.2.1.04,17.012,16]octadecane]-2,2',4',6',8',10',13'-heptaene

141 characters

Good luck and prosperous year 2018!

EDIT

Well, what is a challenge without a prize? So, I have set a bounty worth +50 reputation for the longest name. Sorry, I can not spend much more on it. Remember that you can post more than one structure. If you have proposed one and after some days you find a structure with a longer name, you can post it too.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ How is longest determined? By character count (e.g. using a mono-spaced font) or by the actual physical length using a proportional font. If a proportional font is used, which one? $\endgroup$ – MaxW Dec 23 '17 at 17:43
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ @mhchem You just edited a formula with HTML tags instead of using own package. Should we be worried? $\endgroup$ – andselisk Dec 23 '17 at 18:34
  • 4
    $\begingroup$ @MaxW Just the character count without spaces. Any text editor will do. $\endgroup$ – Raoul Kessels Dec 23 '17 at 18:53
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @andselisk No. Don't worry. If its just 2 subscripts, <sub> does do its job quite well. I'd prefer the MathJax font would not look different to the text font, then I would. $\endgroup$ – mhchem Dec 24 '17 at 20:05
16
$\begingroup$

$\ce{C20H18}$, 246 characters

enter image description here

InChI=1S/C20H18/c1-2-13(1)5-15(13)7-17(15)9-19(17)11-12(19)20(11)10-18(20)8-16(18)6-14(16)3-4-14/h1-4,11-12H,5-10H2/t11-,12+,15-,16-,17-,18-,19-,20-/m1/s1

PIN: (1'R,1''R,1'''R,1''''R,1'''''R,1''''''R,2''''R,3''''S)-octaspiro[tetrakis(cyclopropane)-1,2':1',2'':1'',2''':1''',4''''-bicyclo[1.1.0]butane-2'''',2''''':1''''',2'''''':1'''''',2''''''':1''''''',1''''''''-tetrakis(cyclopropane)]-2,2''''''''-diene

$\endgroup$
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ This is very good. Your approach has given me some further ideas, so you're not safe yet! :< $\endgroup$ – Linear Christmas Jan 4 '18 at 20:39
15
$\begingroup$

$\ce{C20H18}$, 153 characters

(1'S,2'S,3'R,6'S,8'S)-3'-(cycloprop-2-en-1-yl)-11'-[(cycloprop-2-en-1-yl)methylidene]spiro[cyclopropane-1,7'-tricyclo[6.3.0.02,6]undecane]-2,4',9'-triene

enter image description here


P. S. I guess someone should just start, so I simply used the slightly modified structure from the example. I'm pretty sure this one is going to be criticized a lot by experienced organic chemists, so it's more like a kick-starter.

I found it very useful to start with Avogadro first to sketch (and optimize, Ctrl+Alt+O) the initial geometry (very handy for the geometries which are distorted or resembling platonic solids), then import cml file to MarvinSketch and do the rest.

For those who would like to check the names, copy it from here, the press Ctrl+Shift+N, Ctrl+V and click Import in MarvinSketch. For the record, currently MarvinSketch 17.29.0 is being used.

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Thanks for participating!!! We normally use ChemDraw but since MarvinSketch is free, I have set that one so that more people can participate. $\endgroup$ – Raoul Kessels Dec 24 '17 at 10:10
  • $\begingroup$ @RaoulKessels I agree that MarvinSketch might be not that advanced, but it gets the job done, free and is available virtually anywhere, so I fully support your choice:) $\endgroup$ – andselisk Dec 24 '17 at 10:12
  • $\begingroup$ Let's start nitpicking ;) Bonds directing over plane aren't placed properly, it seems. $\endgroup$ – Mithoron Dec 24 '17 at 22:40
12
$\begingroup$

$\ce{C18H20}$ : 145 characters

I was curious as to the isomer with the longest name that had actually been reported in the literature rather than hypothetically proposed (so we at least know it exists).

The IUPAC name, whilst not quite as long as some of the examples, is a respectable 145 characters, largely due to the representation of stereochemistry and connectivity.

(2aR,4aR,4bS,6aS,8aR,8bS)-1,2,7,8-Tetramethyl-2a,4a,4b,6a-tetrahydrocyclobuta[a]cyclobuta[2',3']cyclopenta[1',2':3,4]cyclobuta[1,2-b]cyclopentene

(2aR,4aR,4bS,6aS,8aR,8bS)-1,2,7,8-Tetramethyl-2a,4a,4b,6a-tetrahydrocyclobuta[a]cyclobuta[2',3']cyclopenta[1',2':3,4]cyclobuta[1,2-b]cyclopentene

The molecule was reported in a 2002 paper (J. Org. Chem. 2002, 67 4436–4440) on the rearrangements of a set of spiro[2.4]hepta-1,4,6-trienes

$\endgroup$
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ Are you certain that this PIN is correct? Also, this is $\ce{C18H20}$, not $\ce{C20H18}$ as in the OP. Still interesting, just bad luck. $\endgroup$ – Linear Christmas Dec 28 '17 at 20:18
10
+50
$\begingroup$

Here is my input with character count increasing up to down. I have added InChI codes because it seems MarvinSketch is less capable of reading names than it is in their generation.

1. $\ce{C20H18}$: 164 characters

enter image description here

  • InChI=1/C20H18/c1-11-3-4-12(2)17-16-9-15-13(11)5-6-14(15)18(17)20(16)10-19(20)7-8-19/h3-6,9,13,15H,1,7-8,10H2,2H3/b4-3-,17-12+/t13-,15+,20-/s2

  • PIN: (2'R,4''Z,7''S,11''S)‐3''‐methyl‐6''‐methylidenedispiro[bis(cyclopropane)‐1,1':2',14''‐tetracyclo[8.4.0.02,13.07,11]tetradecane]‐1''(10''),2'',4'',8'',12''‐pentaene

2. $\ce{C20H18}$: 167 characters

enter image description here

  • InChI=1/C20H18/c1-11-3-4-12(2)17-16-9-15-13(11)5-6-14(15)18(17)20(16)10-19(20)7-8-19/h3-8,14-15,18H,2,9-10H2,1H3/b4-3-,13-11-/t14-,15+,18+,20+/s2

  • PIN: (2'S,2''R,3''S,7''R,11''R)‐3''‐methyl‐6''‐methylidenedispiro[bis(cyclopropane)‐1,1':2',14''‐tetracyclo[8.4.0.02,13.07,11]tetradecane]‐1''(10''),2,4'',8'',12''‐pentaene

3. $\ce{C20H18}$: 169 characters

enter image description here

  • InChI=1/C20H18/c1-11-3-4-12(2)17-16-9-15-13(11)5-6-14(15)18(17)20(16)10-19(20)7-8-19/h3-6,9,14,18H,2,7-8,10H2,1H3/b4-3-,13-11-/t14-,18+,20+/s2

  • PIN: (1''S,2'S,4''Z,6''Z,10''S)‐6''‐methyl‐3''‐methylidenedispiro[bis(cyclopropane)‐1,1':2',14''‐tetracyclo[8.4.0.02,13.07,11]tetradecane]‐2''(13''),4'',6'',8'',11''‐pentaene

4. $\ce{C20H18}$: 171 characters

enter image description here

  • InChI=1/C20H18/c1-11-3-4-12(2)17-16-9-15-13(11)5-6-14(15)18(17)20(16)10-19(20)7-8-19/h3-6,9,13,15H,1,7-8,10H2,2H3/b4-3-,17-12+/t13-,15+,20-/s2

  • PIN: (1''S,2'S,4''Z,6''Z,10''R,11''R)‐6''‐methyl‐3''‐methylidenedispiro[bis(cyclopropane)‐1,1':2',14''tetracyclo[8.4.0.02,13.07,11]tetradecane]‐2,2''(13''),4'',6'',8''‐pentaene

5. $\ce{C20H18}$: 172 characters

enter image description here

  • InChI=1/C20H18/c1-11-3-4-12(2)17-16-9-15-13(11)5-6-14(15)18(17)20(16)10-19(20)7-8-19/h3-9,14-15,17-18H,2,10H2,1H3/b4-3-,13-11-/t14-,15+,17+,18+,20+/s2

  • PIN: (1''S,2'R,2''S,4''Z,6''Z,10''R,11''S)‐6''‐methyl‐3''‐methylidenedispiro[bis(cyclopropane)‐1,1':2',14''‐tetracyclo[8.4.0.02,13.07,11]tetradecane]‐2,4'',6'',8'',12''‐pentaene

$\endgroup$
6
$\begingroup$

enter image description here **162 Characters

enter image description here

  • PIN:(1'S,2'S,6'S,7'R,12'S,14'S)‐7'‐methyldispiro[cyclopropane‐1,8'‐pentacyclo[7.5.1.02,6.02,14.012,15]pentadecane‐ 13',1''‐cyclopropane]‐2,2'',3',9'(15'),10'‐ pentaene
  • I have used MarvinSketch 17.28.0 for generating pin.
$\endgroup$
5
$\begingroup$

$\ce{C20H18}$, 290 characters

Heavily based on Daniel Bonniot de Ruisselet's idea, the two "spiraned" cyclopropane pairs next to ending cyclopropenes are fused to bicyclobutanes as well, allowing remaining methyls attachment to the ending cyclopropenes, thus also allowing more chiral centers.

enter image description here

  • PIN: (1S,1′R,1′′′S,1′′′′′R,2′′S,2′′′′S,3′S,3′′′S,3′′′′′S,4′R,4′′′R,4′′′′′R)‐2,3′′′′′′‐dimethylhexaspiro[cyclopropane‐1,2′‐bicyclo[1.1.0]butane‐4′,1′′‐cyclopropane‐2′′,2′′′‐bicyclo[1.1.0]butane‐4′′′,1′′′′‐cyclopropane‐2′′′′,2′′′′′‐bicyclo[1.1.0]butane‐4′′′′′,1′′′′′′‐cyclopropane]‐2,2′′′′′′‐diene
  • InChI=1S/C20H18/c1-7-3-15(7)9-10(15)17(9)5-19(17)13-14(19)20(13)6-18(20)11-12(18)16(11)4-8(16)2/h3-4,9-14H,5-6H2,1-2H3/t9-,10+,11-,12+,13-,14+,15+,16+,17-,18-,19+,20-
  • CXSMILES: [H][C@]12C@([C@@]11C=C1C)[C@]21C[C@]11[C@]2([H])[C@@]1([H])[C@]21C[C@@]11[C@@]2([H])[C@]1([H])[C@@]21C=C1C |c:6,32|
  • gzipped and base64 encoded molfile:

    H4sIAGimq1sCA6WWTW7CMBCF9znFXKDW/PlvXSqxocsepIuev7YjGhFPGrBRhODl5WPmeWyxANy+
    fyixAGYOlChy5gv8vZYFOIB4AGwXtfftlXOGL0bEpX5Tp4EywJsXlxVT1dCVuwjv8Iiwr0bxjmLQ
    SlEnXsSk8Bllq0VdDH66lvopySgl5ZpGpfh8kAs/VYtUSijPHuSCZ5TgAno56Yifp/xTy2ku0Qnl
    s1xOKcmhKM92tFFm0t0oM7ObXNQUZ2d3o8zsRimU6FeK5zSYS92NjCuF6KAjfKWjcUoutQj/daSj
    HaWoLRd2iqSjHYkEnqW0NbJPqevzFO+yIK5ThwUzRml72p666ytr5JHvp9RjLtdXzjofmO67sa7W
    GGU76xKPpcttp9FOFVPV3r562SRor3pTDUfe0P9abDf23mSqudkNr61mi0BoqtRVViTDWyTqMyMx
    vXr34s5rq31mFID87hgvagKKvVq8fcfFyEbH1Lj7taAKMQhGZWUeeH08PE4fc6eWdll6tRC0J5R6
    fa+m+uewI2iNYtfFDeDj87L8Autmps9wCgAA
    

(All data according to MarvinSketch 18.23, image postprocessed in a vector image editor; name postprocessed chem.SE and other text editor - RS italicization and apostrophe to prime replacement.
Marvin obviously has some issues, importing the produced InChI string produces some unspecified centers, so I have generated ChemAxon SMILES, this when pasted produces different stereochemistry, so I have added a compressed MDL molfile as well)

Can someone beat 300 characters, by further modifications?

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.