5
$\begingroup$

Statement 1. The $\ce{HF2-}$ ions exist in solid state and also in liquid state but not in aqueous state.
Statement 2. The magnitude of hydrogen bonding between $\ce{HF}$ is weaker than that between $\ce{HF}$ and $\ce{H2O}$

  1. Both are correct and 2 explains 1
  2. Both are correct but 2 does not explain 1
  3. 1 is correct and 2 false
  4. 2 is correct and 1 false

The answer given is 1.

I know the second statement to be true. $$\Delta H (\ce{H-F...O})=40{-}45\text{ kJ/mol},\Delta H(\ce{H-F...F})=20{-}23\text{ kJ/mol}$$

But I am completely unsure about statement 1 and the relation of the two statements. I think the existence of the afforementioned ion in aqueous solution must not be absent, as I have read somewhere that this ion acts as the conjugate base of the molecule $\ce{H2F2}$ which dissociates into hydrofluoric acid.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Statement one is only true for diluted aqueous solutions. $\endgroup$ – Mithoron Jan 20 '15 at 0:33
2
$\begingroup$

Wikipedia page for for bifluoride anion. The question's answer appears to be true, with explanation and references.

The fluorohydrogenate group $\ce{-HF-}$ in anions such as bifluoride can assimilate a proton by recombination:

$$\ce{HF2- + H+ -> H2F2 -> 2 HF}$$

Because of this capture of a proton ($\ce{H+}$), bifluoride has basic character. Its conjugate acid is the reactive intermediate, μ-fluoro-fluorodihydrogen ($\ce{H2F2}$), which subsequently dissociates to become hydrogen fluoride. In solution, most bifluoride ions are dissociated.

$\ce{HF2- + 3H2O}$ is in a favored equilibrium with $\ce{2H3OF + HO-}$

This makes for an interesting oxygen coordination sphere re the other lone pair of electrons. One presumes it is hydronium fluoride in which the fluoride is bonded to a proton with a delocalized charge.

I've worked with aqueous ammonium hydrogen bifluoride as a silicate etchant. The solution has tremendous surface tension. A drop of Fluorad surfactant was necessary to have things work. $\ce{HF}$ will reach out and eat you. $\ce{NH4HF2}$ is fairly benign. No skin contact! Don't work in Pyrex.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.