Question: (more than one options are correct)

Bond length question

My reasoning:

Option A: is correct as bond length of a pi bond is less than that of a sigma bond, hence a > c as there will be a double bond character in bond a

Option B: there will be an extra resonating structure of b. Hence there will be less double bond character in b than c. So, bond length of b>c. Thus, option B should be incorrect but it is given correct.

Option A and B both are given correct. Moreover, I can't understand how to compare bond lengths in options C an D.


Option A:

$sp^2$ hybridized carbons are more electronegative than $sp^3$ hybridized carbons; hence, the$sp^2$ hybridized carbons try to pull electrons more closely compared to the $sp^3$ hybridized atoms.

In the first molecule, $a$ represents the length of the single bond. Without any doubt, single bonds are longer than double bonds. However, the single bond exists in the first molecule exists between two $sp^2$ hybridized atoms, therefore, the bond length $a$ is shorter than the bond length $b$.

The last molecule is a double bond. This will be shortest as the other two bonds are single bonds.

$$b > a > c$$

Option B:

In the first molecule, there is no resonance stabilization. The electrons of the nitrogen atom of the amine group are not delocalized. The nitrogen-carbon bond in this molecule exists as a single bond.

In the second and third molecule, there is resonance stabilization; therefore, the nitrogen-carbon bond has a partial double bond character.

From the previous two conclusions, we can infer that the $a$ will be the largest among the three.

Between the second and third molecule, the third one has a deactivating group $\ce{NO_2}$. A positive charge in the benzene ring is very destabilizing. The nitrogen atom of the amine group tries to help by delocalizing its electrons for a longer time. Therefore, the partial double bond character of nitrogen-carbon bond in the second molecule is more than that of the third molecule.

$$a > c > b$$

Option C:

While all the three bonds are certainly double bonds, they are connecting different types of atoms.

The first bond ($a$) is a bond between a $sp^2$ hybridized carbon and a $sp$ hybridized carbon.

The second bond ($b$) is a bond between two $sp$ hybridized atoms.

The third bond ($c$) is a bond between a $sp$ hybridized carbon and a $sp^2$ hybridized carbon.

The $sp$ hybridized atoms are more electronegative compared to the $sp^2$ hybridized atoms; therefore, the $sp$ hybridized atoms pull the electrons more strongly towards themselves.

From the above conclusion, we can infer that the length $b$ is going to be the smallest among the three bond lengths.

This molecule is symmetric along the vertical line. Therefore, the bond lengths $a$ and $c$ shall be equal.

$$a = c > b$$

Option D:

Unlike benzene, the carbon–carbon bonds in naphthalene are not of the same length. The bonds C1−C2, C3−C4, C5−C6 and C7−C8 are about 1.37 Å (137 pm) in length, whereas the other carbon–carbon bonds are about 1.42 Å (142 pm) long. This difference, established by X-ray diffraction,[17] is consistent with the valence bond model in naphthalene and in particular, with the theorem of cross-conjugation. This theorem would describe naphthalene as an aromatic benzene unit bonded to a diene but not extensively conjugated to it (at least in the ground state). As such, naphthalene possesses several resonance structures.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naphthalene

$$a < b$$

  • $\begingroup$ Can u explain how the carbon between two benzene rings is sp in the D part . Also if u read the first paragraph of it u will want to make an edit.:) $\endgroup$ – user237650 Mar 16 '17 at 15:09
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Oh, it isn't $sp$. Let me fix it. The correct reason is cross-conjugation. $\endgroup$ – Yashas Mar 16 '17 at 15:41

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.