# Does heavy water taste sweet?

In this YouTube video from Cody's Lab, Cody claims that heavy water tastes sweet.

He does some fairly convincing comparisons but still expresses a little doubt that the effect is real.

Has this been studied by others? Is the effect verified and if so, what possible explanations exist?

• Just as a side note: You might find the vibrational theory of olfaction interesting, see for example en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vibration_theory_of_olfaction – logical x 2 Dec 31 '16 at 16:08
• dude dont try anything of that sort! I just saw that guy drinking cyanide youtube.com/watch?v=bWNpO5vvhpk – Prakhar Dec 31 '16 at 16:12
• @Tetrahydrocannabinol he also took a bite out of sodium metal... – DSVA Dec 31 '16 at 16:21
• I find cold water sweeter than warm water and he did say that heavy water feels colder. – jkd Dec 31 '16 at 19:50
• @Tetrahydrocannabinol - I found Cody's youtube channel a while back, when he was embedding magnets in his fingers. He's certainly ... interesting. But I don't think most people would be advised to do many of the things he does. – Periata Breatta Jan 1 '17 at 16:56

According to H.C. Urey and G. Failla, Science 15 Mar 1935, Vol. 81, Issue 2098, pp. 273, there's no difference in the taste of ordinary and heavy water.

• Very small sample size but an interesting reference indeed! (+1) – Linear Christmas Dec 31 '16 at 15:56

OK, first of all I want to say I really dislike the videos that this guy puts out, since he is promoting unsafe handling of chemicals. He might know what he's doing, but it's a terrible example.

To the actual question: surprisingly there are nearly no sources on this. I can understand that this isn't something a lot of people would try nowadays, but I imagined that a lot of people tried 50 years ago or something like that.

There's one science article describing a blind taste test of three persons in comparison to distilled water, and they couldn't spot a difference.

Another paper describes a difference, and also cites older research that showed that rats avoid $\ce{D2O}$ if they have the option to choose. But that might also be smell. It is known that deuterated substances can have a different smell and taste.

Heavy water also has a higher density and viscosity, so that might also be a factor which makes it "taste" different. Fun fact: it also has a different color.

And well, he didn't do the testing in a scientific manner, which would minimally include blinding the observer.

• Watch the video starting at 6:47. He let his girlfriend (or his sister, or someone, idk) taste taste taste it and she didn't know which tube contained normal water and which one contained heavy water. – UTF-8 Dec 31 '16 at 20:25
• @UTF-8 The odds of it being sheer luck is 50%. No conclusions can be drawn from that. – Fermi paradox Jan 1 '17 at 9:03
• "he is promoting unsafe handling of chemicals" - ..and explosives. I hope he doesn't learn the hard way what static electricity can do to an unstable explosive. – Fermi paradox Jan 1 '17 at 9:08
• @Fermiparadox Well, my sister started studying biology.They had a group visit a lecture.That group tested some gene manipulation on mice. They had 8 mice in total so I guess probably at most 4 which got a treatment. My sister has no idea what's meant by some number and then "sigma" but the group said that everything equal to or above 0.5 σ is relevant for confirming their hypotheses. So if you compare it with what's called "science" in biology ... :D ;-) Of course it's just 2 people on YT allegedly tasting it. But a study involving 3 people stating the opposite isn't exactly meaningful either. – UTF-8 Jan 1 '17 at 9:14
• He explains why biting sodium sounds like a terrible idea, and why his attempt is likely to succeed while warning people not to replicate it. He doesn't mess around doing the same stunt until it kills him and/or others. Was sodium metal generally known to taste tangy and turn tongue tips into soap before? I think not. – Cees Timmerman Jan 1 '17 at 23:03

I tastet heavy water assuming it has not taste and was surprised about the sweet taste (Aldrich, Deuterium oxide, 99.9%). The bottle was old but still sealed. Three more people also defined the content of the same bottle as slightly sweet without knowing what my perception was.

• Please expand on your answer - the OP asks, in addition to if this effect has been studied (not observed) and verified by others, what possible explanations exist. – Todd Minehardt Jan 11 '18 at 15:40