The Oh character table has ten symmetry classes. I am trying to identify them, but my stumbling block is in identifying the order of each class.

I will use this diagram as a reference, from Sydney Kettle's Symmetry and Structure: Readable Group Theory for Chemists pg 191 (Wiley, 3rd edition).

The classes (with their respective orders) for the Oh table are:

$$\begin{array}{cccccccccc}E & 8C_3 & 6C'_2 & 6C_4 & 3C_2 & i & 6S_4 & 8S_6 & 3\sigma_\mathrm{h} & 6\sigma_\mathrm{d}\end{array}$$

  • $E$ and $i$ are obvious.

  • $6C'_2$ and $3C_2$ are shown in the diagram.

  • $8C_3$ is shown in the diagram above; however, it only displays 4 axes. The character table indicates there are 8 equivalent rotations for this symmetry operation. Where do the other 4 axes for the $C_3$ class come from?

  • $6C_4$ is the same issue. It's only shown as 3 axes. Where are the other 3 $C_4$ axes from?

The improper rotations are given in another diagram, this time on page 194 from the same book.

  • The mirror and dihedral planes, $\sigma_\mathrm{h}$ and $\sigma_\mathrm{d}$, are both shown to match the order in the character table.

  • Similar to above for $C_3$ and $C_4$, the $S_4$ and $S_6$ rotations are only half the order supplied in the character table.

In summary, from 10 total classes in the octahedral table, I can identify all the corresponding axes/planes for 6 of those 10 classes. For the remaining 4 classes, $C_3$, $C_4$, $S_4$, and $S_6$, I can only identify half the axes. At first I thought the character table was counting both positive and negative rotations, but then the order for the $C'_2$ and $C_2$ rotations should be doubled if that were the case ($12C'_2$ and $6C_2$).

Can anyone please advise on exactly what the $C_3$, $C_4$, $S_4$, and $S_6$ operations correspond to in an octahedral complex?

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Many rotatable 3D complexes are shown with their symmetry operations in the web site molecule-viewer.com . You can add/remove each of the elements at will. $\endgroup$ – porphyrin Dec 17 '16 at 19:08
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ As porphyrin mentioned, there are pages that show the operations, for example: symmetry.otterbein.edu/gallery/index.html $\endgroup$ – Tyberius Sep 29 '17 at 13:17

At first I thought the character table was counting both positive and negative rotations, but then the order for the $C_2'$ and $C_2$ rotations should be doubled if that were the case ($12C_2'$ and $6C_2$).

You were very close. The missing symmetry operations are indeed ‘positive and negative’ but only those that lead to non-identical transformations. In a $C_2$ axis, it does not matter whether you turn clockwise or counter-clockwise. Consider the following mock-up of the central planar square of an octahedron with the ligands labelled A, B, C and D:

BMD                      (1)

If you apply $C_2$, you will arrive at the same orientation (2), regardless of which direction you rotate in:

DMB                      (2)

However, when rotating by $C_4$ clockwise and counterclockwise actually lead to two different results (3) and (4):

CMA                      (3)

AMC                      (4)

These two are not identical transformations. In fact, they have distinct symbols; depending on your direction of rotation one is $C_4$ and the other is $C_4^3$. You can also interpret them as rotation by $90^\circ$ and rotation by $3 \times 90^\circ = 270^\circ$. $C_2$ and $C_4^2$ correspond to the same transformation as well.

The same case can be made for $C_3$, the reverse rotation is $C_3^2$.

The $S_n$ cases are not quite as simple. Well, actually $S_4$ is ($S_4$ and $S_4^3$) but that’s a coincidence. $S_6$ shows this more clearly. Remember that $$S_6 = C_6 \oplus \sigma_\mathrm{h}$$

Therefore, performing $S_6$ twice is equivalent to $C_3$:

$$S_6 \oplus S_6 = S_6^2 = C_6 \oplus C_6 \oplus \sigma_\mathrm{h} \oplus \sigma_\mathrm{h} = C_3 \oplus E = C_3$$

Thus, $S_6$ applied twice and $S_6^5$ applied twice give $C_3$ and $C_3^2$, respectively, so $S_6^2$ and $S_6^4$ are already taken care of. A last case needs to be made for $S_6^3$: This is identical to $i$ as can be seen below:

$$S_6^3 = S_6 + S_6 + S_6 = C_6 \oplus C_6 \oplus C_6 \oplus \sigma_\mathrm{h} \oplus \sigma_\mathrm{h} \oplus \sigma_\mathrm{h} = C_2 \oplus \sigma_\mathrm{h} = i$$

Thus, while you could imagine up to six different $S_6$ transformations, only two of those ($S_6$ and $S_6^5$) give new transformations not covered elsewhere.

| improve this answer | |

Keep in mind that a class doesn't indicate equivalent symmetry elements, merely equivalent operations.

For example, given $\ce{O_h}$, the ${C_3}$ and ${C_3^2}$ operations are class-equivalent. You're correct that there are only 4 axes, so the other 4 operations are ${C_3^2 = C_3^{-1}}$. Similarly, the 4 ${C_4}$ axes generate the ${C_4}$ operations and their inverse - which are in the same class: ${C_4^3 = C_4^{-1}}$.

It's similar with ${S_4}$ and ${S_6}$.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.