Suppose that I have a cast-iron pot which my awful roommate has vigorously scrubbed with soap and left to soak in soapy water over the weekend. The seasoning has been destroyed and replaced with awful-tasting soapy contaminants.

It seems to me that the simplest and best way to deal with this is to heat the pot over a campfire until only black carbon remains, then clean and reseason.

Not knowing exactly what is in my awful roommate's dish soap, and being a very fussy foodie, I want to be conservative here... so how hot would I have to heat the pot, and for how long, to be quite sure that virtually nothing but carbon remains?

Edit: Compare using the self-cleaning cycle of an oven for similar purpose, reported to work well...


There's a lot of exciting, and not well defined, chemistry that happens with seasoning cast-iron cookware. Essentially, you are creating a cross-linked polymer film that is hydrophobic, providing a "stick-free" surface. There are many many websites claiming the "best way" to season (or re-season) cast-iron cookware. Few of these sites (and I'll let the OP and visitors search for those on their own) are based on science. (Although I am not going to question tried and true family secrets, passed down from generation to generation.) One site in particular makes a fairly convincing argument for seasoning that is science-based. I suggest this approach can help restore your pot.

I suspect what has happened is that the scrubbing did remove the seasoning and exposed base metal to water and oxidation - your pot rusted. The "soapy contaminants" is probably iron oxide rather than something from the dishwater, although there are such products as metal soaps which are metals chelated to long-chain fatty acids.

As for heating the pot to burn off all the residue - I doubt this is the most effective use of your time. Scrubbing with acidified water to remove the iron oxide and a long seasoning session with an easily cross-linkable oil should get your pot back to (or better than) original condition.

  • $\begingroup$ It actually is just a hypothetical - came up in a Reddit discussion - do you happen to know the answer to the question as posed literally, even though I'll take your advice if I ever need to reseason a pot for real? $\endgroup$ – Evan Harper Oct 4 '13 at 15:56

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.