For example, if a question asks for $[\ce{H+}]$ of a $0.100~\mathrm{M}$ solution of picric acid (monoprotic), given that its $K_\mathrm{a}$ at the system temperature is $4.2 \times 10^{-1},$ following my teacher's instructions I would use the ICE table, which looks like this (for a different example).

$$\begin{array}{cccccccc} & \ce{CO (g)} & + & \ce{H2O (g)} & \ce{<=>} & \ce{CO2 (g)} & + & \ce{H2 (g)} \\ \text{Initial} & 0.100~\mathrm{M} & & 0.100~\mathrm{M} & & 0 & & 0 \\ \text{Change} & -x~\mathrm{M} & & -x~\mathrm{M} & & x~\mathrm{M} & & x~\mathrm{M} \\ \text{Equilibrium} & (0.100-x)~\mathrm{M} & & (0.100-x)~\mathrm{M} & & x~\mathrm{M} & & x~\mathrm{M} \\ \end{array}$$

I would then solve for $x$ by using the expression for $K_\mathrm{a}$. However, since $0.100/K_\mathrm{a} < 100$ (lowest initial concentration divided by $K_\mathrm{a}$ is less than 100), $x$ is significant and cannot be omitted from the $0.100-x$. Thus, you need to use the quadratic equation, which yields two solutions for my example above: $x=0.0834, 0.503$. The latter is obviously incorrect because it is greater than the initial concentration of the undissociated compound.

However, my question is: Is it possible that both solutions to a given reaction will be nontrivial, that is, is it possible that both answers appear to work at a glance? (No conflicts with the initial concentration, etc.) This question refers not specifically to the example in question, but rather looks at if it is possible at all (is there a reaction and starting concentration for which both answers would seem correct). In addition, if it is possible, how would one determine which answer is nontrivially impossible?

Whenever I get into a new subject I'm not able to "do" it until I work out some small details that stick with me. It would be best if the answer had some logical explanation, or even a proof as to why the two answers will never be both possible at a glance, or if the answer shows a way to determine without fail which answer is correct. I don't see an obvious reason why both solutions resulting from the quadratic equation will always have one blatantly incorrect result.

Please ask for clarifications if necessary.

  • $\begingroup$ This has no real bearing on the question itself, but please pay attention to your units. Prior to my edit, the way you earlier defined $x$ in the ICE table, $x$ needed to have units of concentration. It cannot be a pure number because then $0.100~\mathrm{M} - x$ makes no sense. You either define $x$ as a dimensionless quantity, or define $x$ as a concentration and then tack the units along with it. Either way is fine but just be consistent. $\endgroup$ Nov 22, 2016 at 11:28
  • $\begingroup$ With more complicated systems, you might end up with a cubic or even a higher order equation. Still, the nature guarantees the existence of a unique physically meaningful solution, no matter what. $\endgroup$ Nov 22, 2016 at 14:04

1 Answer 1


What you have got here is a strong acid ($\mathrm{p}K_\mathrm{a} \approx 0.38$) that is not diluted, whereof the latter tells you that you can safely ignore the autoprotolysis of water.

The pH approximation to choose is therefor: $$[\ce{H+}] = \frac{[\ce{HA}]_0 K_\mathrm{a}}{[\ce{H+}] + K_\mathrm{a}}$$

or in a quadratic form: $$[\ce{H+}]^2 + [\ce{H+}] K_\mathrm{a} - [\ce{HA}]_0 K_\mathrm{a} = 0$$

which has two solutions: $$[\ce{H+}] = -\frac{K_\mathrm{a}}{2} \pm \sqrt{\left(\frac{K_\mathrm{a}}{2}\right)^2 + [\ce{HA}]_0 K_\mathrm{a}}$$

From those two solutions, only one is chemically meaningful, which is the positive combination which yields one of your solutions ... $[\ce{H+}] = 0.0834$.

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Just to make it crystal clear for OP: the other solution is meaningless because it's negative. $\endgroup$ Nov 22, 2016 at 11:20
  • $\begingroup$ The question is asking in general, not specifically referring to the example. I've edited the question to make it more clear. $\endgroup$
    – Jack Pan
    Nov 23, 2016 at 0:30
  • $\begingroup$ It's impossible to have two meaningful results for a pH calculation as a solution simply can't have two pH values. $\endgroup$ Nov 23, 2016 at 19:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.