Suppose a protein side chain has a $\ce{-SH}$ group which is partially deprotonated to thiolate anion $\ce{-S -}$. This thiolate can perform a nucleophilic attack on a certain substrate.

Will the propensity of nucleophilic attack be reduced if the thiolate anion is in electrostatic interaction with a $\ce{NH3+}$ group of a basic amino acid? Or is the likelihood of nucleophilic attack independent of electrostatic effects?

P.S.- The $\ce{-S-}$ will probably be in eletrostatic interaction with H+ in the solution also. Maybe electrostatic interaction with $\ce{NH3+}$ will be more stable?

Core question: If a negative nucleophile is in electrostatic interaction, will it affect its nucleophilicity?


It would since the S atom is now negatively charged. However, S is a very poor hydrogen-bond acceptor as evidenced by its weak basicity (thiols are more acidic than alcohols). So this electrostatic effect will be greatly diminished if you compare with more basic nucleophiles like F- and O-. This is because sulfur larger and will be more polorizable making the localization of the negative charge more disperse around the atom and much weaker to form ion-ion interactions. It will still remain as a relatively powerful nucleophile, so you can expect side reactions.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.