I have a question about when to use H3O+ and when to use the actual compound. I'm not really sure how to word this question so I'll show you an example of what I mean.

Example of using H3O:

"A titration for a sample of 25mL of 0.1 M NH3 by 0.1M HCl is conducted. Calculate the pH after the addition of 12 mL of 0.1M HCl"

$\ce{NH3 + H3O -> NH3 + H2O} $ (etc)

Example using the compound:

"Calculate the pH of 75 mL of 0.1M HC2H3O2 and .2M of NaC2H3O2 to which 9.5mL of 0.1M HCL is added"

$\ce{C2H3O2- + HCl -> HC2H3O2 + Cl-}$ (etc)

My question is, when are we supposed to use HCl in the equation and when are we supposed to use H3O+? Is it only when you are using a buffer that you are to use HCl? If so, why is this?


1 Answer 1


In both your cases, only H+ actually participates in the reaction. Remember that HCl is a strong acid, and dissociates completely into H+ and Cl-. For example, consider the net ionic form of your second equation:

$\ce{C2H3O2- + HCL -> HC2H3O2 + Cl-}$

$\ce{C2H3O2- + (H+) + Cl- -> HC2H3O2 + Cl-}$

$\ce{C2H3O2- + H+ -> HC2H3O2}$

For your first equation, also note that, similarly, although the entire H30+ molecule participates in the reaction, only the H+ is transferred. (Also, I think you meant NH4+ instead of NH3 as a product.) So:

$\ce{NH3 + (H3O)+ -> NH4+ H2O}$

$\ce{NH3 + H+ -> NH4+}$

So basically, they both use the same compound (H+). Usually water is the main producer of H+ (through self-ionization). You just need to consider factors such as the common ion effect that would make other compounds such as HCl the main producer of H+ instead of water.

  • $\begingroup$ This link may be useful in order to learn how to format chemical equations on this site. $\endgroup$ Apr 27, 2016 at 4:47

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.