3
$\begingroup$

I understand the following definition of a hydrogen bond from Merriam Webster:

an electrostatic attraction between a hydrogen atom in one polar molecule (as of water) and a small electronegative atom (as of oxygen, nitrogen, or fluorine) in usually another molecule of the same or a different polar substance

However, I wasn't sure if this applied to F, N, or O atoms that were not covalently bonded to H in the first place. A question regarding hydrogen-bonding came up on an exam for which the marks scheme read that both element X (with an O-H bond) and element Y (with an O in an ether group). However my teacher doesn't not agree with the marks scheme and, "[believes that the marks-scheme is] incorrect because Y doesn't contain O-H bonds so the O will not carry a large enough δ- to create hydrogen bonds with water."

Is she correct, or is the marks scheme?

Exam Marks-scheme versus My Teacher

Note: I thought the same as my teacher up until I saw the MS.

$\endgroup$
  • 5
    $\begingroup$ The answer sheet is correct. Your teacher is mistaken (polite way to say flat out wrong). $\endgroup$ – MaxW Jan 25 '16 at 3:26
  • 5
    $\begingroup$ Indeed hydrogen bonds are not just restricted to fluorine, oxygen and nitrogen either. They may be found to other elements in some cases. Additionally, they are not just electrostatic interactions - they contain a significant covalent component. $\endgroup$ – bon Jan 25 '16 at 8:15
6
$\begingroup$

Hydrogen-bonds require a $\delta^+$ hydrogen atom attached to an electronegative element, i.e. O, F, N, or Cl, and also an "active" lone pair on another electronegative atom. An electrostatic attraction between these two is an extremely strong kind of intermolecular dipole-dipole interaction.

Compounds which have O-H or N-H groups are able to both form hydrogen-bonds through the $\ce \delta^+$H atom and accept hydrogen-bonds through the lone pair on the oxygen or nitrogen. These compounds tend to have higher then expected melting and boiling points due to the hydrogen-bonding. Compounds are even able to form internal hydrogen-bonds with other O or N atoms in the structure.

However hydrogen bonding can occur between substances that cannot form the bonds with their own molecules. Because compound Y is an ether and can only accept hydrogen-bonds there are fewer bonds made overall between the mixture of substances, so the effect on the physical properties isn't so great. Nonetheless water can form hydrogen-bonds through its proton and functional groups such as ethers, esters, amines, amides, alcohols and carboxylic acids can all accept those bonds through the relevant lone pairs.

Another example would be a tertiary amine such as $\ce{N(CH3)3}$, which is miscible with water because of the hydrogen bonds it accepts from the water molecules even though it has no N-H bonds itself. Even $\ce{N(C2H5)3}$ is miscible with water at room temperature, and other tertiary amines continue to be soluble in water for the same reason: they are hydrogen-bond acceptors.

So the mark scheme is correct, and the teacher has shown a poor understanding of intermolecular interactions.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.