What will happen in the following reactions? This is Problem 3d from Chapter 6 of Zweifel and Nantz's Modern Organic Synthesis.

Treatment of isomeric hydroxyketones with TsCl and KOtBu

I thought that after the hydroxyl group is converted into a good leaving group ($\ce{OTs}$), an enolate would be formed which would attack $\ce{CH_2OTs}$, but I guess the fused cyclobutane thus obtained would be too strained. What else could happen?

  • $\begingroup$ There is a solution manual to the book which essentially fully supports the accepted answer. $\endgroup$ Aug 27, 2018 at 17:28

1 Answer 1


I went looking for this question again today after talking to someone about a similar reaction, then realised I never got round to trying to actually answer it.

Leading reference: Tetrahedron 1969, 25 (21), 5267–5274.

In the first case, with the trans-fused ring system, we first get tosylation as expected. Using the bulky potassium tert-butoxide, we get enolate formation at the least hindered alpha position. This enolate is then setup, as can be seen in the conformational diagram below, to displace the tosylate forming the new ring. This is confirmed in the cited literature.

Traction of trans-decalin system

In the second case, with the cis-fused ring system, things are a little more complicated. Once again we get tosylation, however the the cis-fused product can be drawn in multiple 3D conformations, only one of which is productive (shown in orange below).

enter image description here

In this case, the steric argument for enolate formation doesn't hold, as the thermodynamic enolate is unproductive, and as such only the enolate formed at the most hindered position goes forward to form the product.

As you mentioned in your initial post, "the obtained structure would be too strained", which is what prevented me from thinking this pathway happened in the first place. However, looking at the original Tetrahedron paper, they do have evidence to back up the formation of these ring systems. One possible conclusion is that due to the conformational preferences of the 6,6-ring systems, the bonds are closer together than you'd maybe expect, meaning there isn't such a penalty to formation of the cyclobutane.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.