I'm reading about $\:\mathrm{S_N1}$ and $\:\mathrm{S_N2}$ reaction mechanisms, and I have a few questions.

My book has a couple of tables, one lists a bunch of substances grouped as good, moderate and poor nucleophiles. Among the good are $\ce{Br-}$ and $\ce{I-}$. So a couple of halogens. I'm figuring chlorine is in that group too.

Then it has a table showing ability to function as leaving group. Iodine, bromine and chlorine anions are at the top of that list too.

My question is: How can these be quite attracted to the positive charge AND quite easy to remove at the same time?


1 Answer 1


I'm not entirely sure of this, comments appreciated

Leaving group tendency is a thermodynamic variable. So, it depends more on the equilibrium and energies of the reaction. We calculate it from the basicity of the group (weak base -> more stable while solvated -> better leaving group).

Now, iodide is a weaker base than $\ce{OH-}$, since its conjugate acid $\ce{HI}$ is a stronger acid than $\ce{H2O}$. So, iodine is a better leaving group.

On the other hand, nucleophilic tendency is basically "how willing to sacrifice a lone pair is the group?". It's more dependent on forces, and less on energy, as it is a kinetic phenomenon. The outer shell electrons in $\ce{I-}$ are more loosely bonded to it than those in oxygen in $\ce{OH-}$. So, it is a better nucleophile.

Another way to look at it would be via the "accessibility" of the group in solution. This basically attempts to explain the difference between a nucleophile and a leaving group. In a leaving group, you have to "give up" the ion to the solution. This means that solvation doesn't really matter here -- once you've given it up, it's gone. The process will have a similar rate for different ions. However, when looking at the reverse process, you need to check how solvated the ion is. If the ion is surrounded by water molecules (like $\ce{F-}$, it will be much harder for the electrophile to "extract" it. On the other hand, an ion like $\ce{I-}$ is less solvated, and thus more "accessible".

  • $\begingroup$ To further contrast with the "leaving group tendency", nucleophilicity is a kinetic phenomenon. $\endgroup$
    – Ben Norris
    Feb 17, 2013 at 2:10
  • $\begingroup$ @BenNorris: ? That's already there, see the third paragraph :) $\endgroup$ Feb 17, 2013 at 5:21
  • $\begingroup$ Doesnt the size of the nucleophile play a vital role? Because iodide is huge wouldnt it have more of a basic nature than nucleophlic nature. $\endgroup$
    – Shubham
    Mar 16, 2016 at 16:10
  • $\begingroup$ Why is a weak base more stable when solvated? Shouldn't it be the other way round? $\endgroup$ Aug 4, 2016 at 6:32

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.