Find the major product of the following reaction.

enter image description here


First step would be the formation of oxonium ion. After that, there are two possibilities. Either the upper double bond or the lower bond will shift and create a carbocation (A and B)

enter image description here

In product A there are two possible migrations. The better migrating group is the carbon which is a part of the second ring. But it can't migrate because of formation of a bridged carbocation. So methyl group migrates.

enter image description here

If B carbocation is formed, then the better migrating group can attack the carbocation.

enter image description here

My teacher told that the product A is wrong because a weaker migrating group is acting while in B, the stronger migrating group is acting. Is this correct? Because B involves ring contraction and more steps.

  • $\begingroup$ Incidentally, the structures labeled A and B are resonance structures, i.e., the same compound. $\endgroup$
    – jerepierre
    Nov 17, 2015 at 19:31

1 Answer 1


Your analysis of the possible products is excellent. I would consider both of the products to be major. Waring and coworkers studied this problem with a slightly different substrate (an extra methyl group at the 1-position, next to the carbonyl on the 'bottom' of the molecule). Under aqueous acidic conditions (sulfuric acid), the corresponding products were obtained in ~25% (mechanism A) and ~40% yield (product B). Only when run with sulfuric acid in acetic anhydride did mechanism B truly dominate (~90% vs 5% mechanism A).

There is actually a third pathway, where the methyl group shifts from ring juncture to ring juncture, and then goes through a mechanism similar to B. For the dienone in the question, the product is indistinguishable from mechanism B, but for the dienone studied in the publication, this gave another product in ~30% yield. I suspect that for the dienone in the question, the total yield of product B would be ~70%. That makes it appear as if mechanism B is dominant, but it is really two similar pathways operating that happen to give the same product.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.