32
$\begingroup$
  • What is a non-classical carbocation?
  • How is it different from a classical carbocation?

I am confused as I have come across this term many times on Chem.SE but there seems to be nothing for my level of understanding on the Internet!

$\endgroup$
24
$\begingroup$

Here is a picture of a "classical" carbocation, there is an electron deficient carbon bearing a positive charge.

enter image description here

There are many examples of "non-classical" carbocations, but the 2-norbornyl carbocation is among the best known.

Norbornyl

Labeling experiments have shown that the positive charge resides on more than one carbon in the 2-norbornyl ion. Early on, the data was explained by equilibrating classical ions, but soon another possibility emerged - one involving a single non-classical ion.

The problem comes down to: are the equilibrating classical ions ground state structures with the non-classical ion serving as the transition state, or is the non-classical ion the ground state? This debate went on for a very long period of time, but now most agree that the non-classical structure is the ground state in the 2-norbornyl system. In fact, a recent, and difficult to obtain, crystal structure for the 2-norbornyl cation has been published proving that the ion exists with the non-classical geometry (thanks to Klaus for finding this reference, see his comment below).

enter image description here

A key difference between classical and non-classical structures is the bonding. As illustrated above, a classical ion has a carbon with a sextet of electrons and 3 other bonds. The non-classical ion, on the other hand, involves 3 carbons with 2 electrons spread over them. This is called a 3-center 2-electron bond (hypercoordinate bonding) and is a clear marker for a non-classical ion. Notice if you count all of the bonds to any of these 3 carbon atoms (solid and dashed lines) you count 5! Sounds strange, but such "hypercoordinate bonding" is a permitted consequence of the 3-center 2-electron bond.

enter image description here

Here is a link to a simpler non-classical carbocation discussed here yesterday.

$\endgroup$
  • 11
    $\begingroup$ In addition to the link that you gave for the last image, the report in Science, 2013, 341, 62-64 might be worth to be linked too. The decade-long debate concerning the non-classical nature of the 2-norbornyl cation has been settled. $\endgroup$ – Klaus-Dieter Warzecha May 20 '15 at 19:42

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.