According to Wikipedia, tin-112 is a stable nuclide, but indium-112 is radioactive (half-life only 14 minutes). What is the explanation for this?


For isobars (i.e. nuclides with a constant mass number $A$), the binding energy $E$ as a function of the atomic number $Z$ describes a parabola, the so-called valley of β-stability (see also Weizsäcker’s formula or semi-empirical mass formula).

$$E = a \cdot Z^2 + b \cdot Z + c \pm d/A^{3/4}$$

The most stable nuclides lie at the bottom of the valley (but not necessarily exactly at the minimum of the parabola). Isobars with lower atomic numbers $Z$ are unstable to $\beta^-$ decay. Isobars with higher atomic numbers $Z$ are unstable to $\beta^+$ decay or electron capture. Therefore, at least one of two adjacent isobars must be radioactive (see Mattauch isobar rule).

Thus, since Sn-112 is stable, we expect In-112 to be radioactive.

The last term $(\pm d/A^{3/4})$ gives rise to three different parabola depending on whether the nuclides are even-$A$ (with even $Z$ and even $N$), even-$A$ (with odd $Z$ and odd $N$), or odd-$A$ (with even $Z$ and odd $N$, or with odd $Z$ and even $N$).
In the last case, in which the mass number $A$ is odd, the result is a single parabola with one stable nuclide at the bottom.
However, for even mass numbers $A$, we find two parabolas; the odd-odd-curve always lies above the even-even curve. Hence, it is possible that two or even three stable isobars exist.

The case with two parabolas also applies to your example. The stable nuclide Sn-112 has 50 protons and 62 neutrons (even-even). The radioactive nuclide In-112 has 49 protons and 63 neutrons (odd-odd). The next neighbour, Cd-112 has 48 protons and 64 neutrons (even-even) and is stable.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.