Mixtures of ethanol and acetone have vapor pressures that are higher than predicted by Raoult's law, while mixtures of acetone and water have lower vapor pressures than predicted by Raoult's law. Why is this?

That is, why is there a "positive deviation" from Raoult's law for acetone/ethanol solutions but a "negative deviation" for acetone/water?

Isn't an acetone-ethanol hydrogen bond stronger than an acetone-acetone hydrogen bond? If the reason for the positive deviation of the ethanol/acetone solution is that the H bonds there are weaker than ethanol-ethanol H bonds, then there wouldn't that imply that acetone/water solutions would also have a positive deviation, as water-water H bonds must be much stronger than water-acetone, right?

So is there some other explanation?

  • $\begingroup$ What do you mean by "positive" and "negative" deviations? Does positive mean that the vapor pressure above the liquid is higher than Raoult's law would predict (or vice versa)? $\endgroup$ – Curt F. Mar 12 '15 at 16:45
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Yes. That is what I meant to say. $\endgroup$ – Dhruva Patil Mar 12 '15 at 16:50
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks much for clarifying. One more question: is the deviation positive for both components? I.e. is the vapor pressure of both acetone and ethanol higher than Raoult's law would predict, or just one component? $\endgroup$ – Curt F. Mar 12 '15 at 17:09
  • $\begingroup$ I couldn't find any information on that. They are just listed as examples under positive and negative deviation. It is also given that water and ethanol forms a solution that deviates positively like acetone and ethanol, if that helps in any way. $\endgroup$ – Dhruva Patil Mar 12 '15 at 17:51
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Thank you for the link. Interesting analogy. But the problem is not that I don't understand the reason for the deviations in general, but it is that I can't make sense of this particular case. Is there something more to consider? Is it more complex than comparing the A-B interactions of different solutions with common components? $\endgroup$ – Dhruva Patil Mar 14 '15 at 14:18

First some general comments about Raoults law before discussing the particular solutions in question.

Raoult’s law suggests that the partial pressure of each substance above a solution is proportional to its mole fraction x, thus $p=p^ox$ where $p^o$ is the vapour pressure of the pure substance.

Experimentally there are deviations from Raoult’s law and they can be in both the ‘positive’ and ‘negative’ direction. A positive deviation means that p is greater than expected from Raoult’s law and thus a negative deviation has pressure that is less than expected. Alcohol/water mixtures show positive deviations and for example acetone/chloroform negative deviations.

The reason for these deviations is due to the different interaction between the molecules. The change in interaction on adding one liquid to another is due to the difference in interaction energies between them, thus if the energies between the same type of molecules of type 1 and 2 is $E_{11}$ and $E_{22}$ (which can be positive or negative) we can write the difference in energy as $$ \Delta E = c(E_{12} - E_{11}/2 - E_{22}/2)$$ where c is a constant to account or the fact that molecule of type 1 and 2 are different. A positive value of $\Delta E$ indicates that the interaction between types 1 and 2 is less attractive than either molecule to itself and a negative value that types 1 and types 2 will prefer to interact with the other type of molecules than themselves.

All atoms have dispersion interaction (induced dipole-induced-dipole) due to their polarisability, and in addition may have permanent dipoles, (causing dipole-dipole and induced-dipole energies) and hydrogen bond interactions. Clearly which contribute depends on the particular case being studied.

Starting with the chemical potential and the interaction energy it is possible to calculate the partial pressure as a function of mole fraction and energy $\Delta E$ and this is

$$ \frac{p}{p^o}=x\exp(+(1-x)^2\Delta E^o)$$

where $\Delta E^o = \Delta E/kT$ where k is Boltzmann’s constant and T temperature. This function is shown in the figure for different values of $\Delta E^o$. When this is positive there is a positive deviation from Raoult’s law, a $\Delta E^o = 1$ approximately describes the ethanol/ water data and $\Delta E^o = -0.5$ the acetone/chloroform data. (The maximum $\Delta E^o = 2$ since above this phase separation occurs)


figure: calculated pressure vs molec fraction x. Positive deviation $\Delta E^o > 0$ and negative deviation $\Delta E^o < 0$. Raoult's law $\Delta E^o = 0$

Now for the particular solutions mentioned, ethanol-acetone has a positive deviation and thus $\Delta E^o > 0$. It is not really possible without some (spectroscopic) experimental data to say what interaction causes this; most likely it is slight changes of each type of interaction, but probably mainly changes in dipole-dipole and hydrogen bonding. The data indicates that acetone-ethanol interactions are less favourable than either molecule with itself.

In the acetone - water data the interaction between these two types of molecules is more favourable in such a way as to overcome the sum of water-water and acetone-acetone interaction energies. This is somewhat unusual for water as it is a highly associated (i.e. hydrogen bonded) liquid and a second component tends to break up this association.

We must conclude, however, that the acetone is able to become solvated in such a way as to disrupt the water structure but still be of lower energy than the sum of water-water and acetone-acetone interactions. Again only spectroscopic evidence will indicate what the interactions are; without this we can only speculate but it could be that the main gain comes from removing acetone-acetone interactions and replacing them by water-acetone even though the water-water interaction is favourable, losing some of this interaction must be compensated for by gaining acetone-water ones.

| improve this answer | |
  • $\begingroup$ How is interaction energy defined/calculated? $\endgroup$ – Apekshik Panigrahi Mar 24 '19 at 7:56
  • $\begingroup$ This is where these simple thermodynamic models break down. You could find the energy by fitting the data to one of the curves, and then compare with calculation of general van-der-Waals forces between molecules, i.e. any or all of ion-ion, ion-dipole, dipole-dipole, induced dipole -induced dipole and so on as appropriate. $\endgroup$ – porphyrin Mar 24 '19 at 8:42

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.