15
$\begingroup$

Over the last year or so I've heard from friends, who subscribe to holistic medicine, talk about negative ions, saying that they are good for your mental/physical health. Being the only one among them with a chemistry background, I was suspicious when i heard this. Below are examples I've seen that use negative ions in a medicinal context:

Negative Ions Purify Air

Virtually all particles in the air have a positive charge, while negative ions have a negative charge. In which case, negative ions and particles magnetically attract to one another. When there is a high enough concentration of negative ions in the air, they will attract to floating particles in large numbers. This causes the particle to become too heavy to remain airborne. As a result, the particle will fall out of the air, and will then be collected by normal cleaning activities, such as vacuuming or dusting. - Ion-Imbalance

Negative Ions from the Beach

You may have experienced the power of negative ions when you last set foot on the beach or walked beneath a waterfall. While part of the euphoria is simply being around these wondrous settings and away from the normal pressures of home and work, the air circulating in the mountains and the beach is said to contain tens of thousands of negative ions -- Much more than the average home or office building, which contain dozens or hundreds, and many register a flat zero. -WebMD

Apparently they Help You Breath

People travel from all over the world to visit salt mines like the ones found in the Himalayas, Austria, and Germany. In Germany, the hot salt springs are so revered, companies often send overworked employees there to rejuvenate. Why are the salt mines so beneficial? Quite simply... the very dry, negative ion environment of a salt mine is key. Well... even if you're not able to travel to Asia or Europe to take advantage of salt mines, you can still take advantage of these negative ions to help improve the air you breathe. The solution involves pure Himalayan crystal salt...- Mercola

Well it's not surprising that two thirds of the above sources are trying to sell products (salt lamps, air purifiers).

Since we're dealing with ions here, I figure the chemistry world must have some sort of input. What's the chemical or biochemical support, or the evidence against, for the above claims? If there are negative ions present from waterfalls/oceans/salt rocks, what ions are we talking about?


To address @dissenter, one of these sites claims tourmaline is a source of negative ions...

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I think some relevant questions are: 1) are gas-phase ions easily formed at STP and 2) what are these gas-phase ions that your sources speak specifically of. $\endgroup$ – Dissenter Dec 28 '14 at 2:11
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Tourmaline is definitely not a source of ions, either positive or negative. $\endgroup$ – Gimelist Dec 28 '14 at 11:02
16
$\begingroup$

Charge separation at waterfalls with airborne ions, resulting in a potential between the base of the waterfall and the surrounding air, is a phenomenon examined by Philipp Lenard (Über die Elektrizität der Wasserfälle, Ann Phys (Leipz), 1892, 46, 584–636).

The effect is real and more recent field studies, such as Characterization of ions at Alpine waterfalls, as well as studies on the formation of charged droplets, such as Charge Separation in the Aerodynamic Breakup of Micrometer-Sized Water Droplets should be taken seriously.

However, the sources that you cited are pseudoscientific marketing bullshit.

The first quote links to a web shop that offers marvels like magnetic bands and ion-balance bands. While the silicone band probably isn't hamful to the skin, it will not emit anything. Nada, nothing, nix!

The webshop behind the third link sells Himalayan salt lamps. It's a matter of taste to have a lamp housing made from unrefined sodium chloride with traces of iron in it (hence the colour), but I wouldn't expect any health effects through the emission of whatever from these lifestyle items. Himalayan salt is being sold for quite a while, even for nutrition but if at all, the stuff has seen the Himalaya mountains only from a distance.

There are no halite mines in the Himalaya mountains.

Instead, the material is likely to come from the Salt Range in the Punjab province in Pakistan, or from Poland.

In summary, it's business as usual: Scientific facts are mashed up with esoteric mumbo jumbo to sell overpriced and useless stuff to well-meaning but naive clients.

Oh what a tangled web we weave,
When first we practise to deceive!
-- Sir Walter Scott

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.