# Hydrocarbons with only 4 carbon atoms

How many different organic structures (from the pure theoretical viewpoint) can be drawed with only 4 (exact) carbon atoms and with/without hydrogen? Polycyclic compounds and bridged compounds are also allowed. Please, name them all as well! :)

Remark: I have drawed the chemical graphs in a piece of paper (the skeletons) and I get 37 graphs (including linear with simple, double and triple bonds, and planar and nonplanar compounds), without geometric isomerism (cis/trans). Is that OK?

• I top out at 23. I'd be curious to see your list. – jerepierre Nov 13 '14 at 18:25
• I think pentavalent carbon is more realistic than some of those: scs.illinois.edu/denmark/presentations/2007/gm-2007-04-17.pdf – DavePhD Nov 13 '14 at 21:05
• There is also cis/trans 2-butene in real world. In theoretical world you could draw cis/trans isomers for some cyclobutenes too – K_P Nov 13 '14 at 21:10
• @Ron Because carbon can bond hydrogens, not just other carbons. – DavePhD Nov 14 '14 at 12:14
• @riemannium I moved your answer to a comment up here. If it was directed at anyone in particular, you can copy and paste it as a comment to the answer that you were replying to. – jonsca Nov 14 '14 at 20:22

Final update, all earlier edits incorporated.

Groundrules: Considering compounds with:

• only carbon and hydrogen
• only 4 bonds to carbon

There are 37 isomers without considering trans isomers; 49 when trans isomers are included. Also, many of these compounds seem extremely unstable and therefore unlikely to exist.

Note to self: check back in 20 years and see how many of the unlikely ones have been detected.

Names by row:

• butane, isobutane
• but-1-ene, but-2-ene, 2-methylpropene
• buta-1,3-diene, buta-1,2-diene, buta-1,2,3-triene
• but-1-yne, but-2-yne, but-1-ene-3-yne, buta-1,3-diyne
• methylcyclopropane, 2-methylcyclopropene, 1-methylcyclopropene, methylenecyclopropane, methylenecyclopropene, methlycyclopropadiene
• methylcyclopropyne, methlenecyclopropyne
• cyclobutane, cyclobutene, cyclobuta-1,2-diene, cyclobuta-1,3-diene, cyclobutatriene, cyclobutatetraene, cyclobutyne, cyclobutenyne, cyclobutadiyne
• bicyclobutane, bicyclobut-1(3)-ene, bicyclobut-1(2)-ene, bicyclobuta-1,3-diene, bicyclobuta-1,2-diene
• Comparing with my skeletons, you lack a 1methyl-cyclopropene, and the cyclobutatriene with 3 double bonds (irrespectively it existed or not, you have not drawed it). Also, you have not drawed the C4 (the square with 4 double bonds). Thus, I get 36 (or 37, if I include the cis/trans versions of 2-butene, that I had not considered diferent so far). – riemannium Nov 14 '14 at 0:24
• @ron You might want to include a note for posterity that some of these "compounds" are incredibly strained and likely unstable. (This was why I was including ?? marks in my answer.) – Geoff Hutchison Nov 14 '14 at 0:45
• @GeoffHutchison There is a higher than normal barrier to rotation about the 2,3-bond in 1,3-butadiene due to a contribution from the resonance structure with a 2-3 double bond. However, the barrier is still low enough that the s-cis and s-trans forms are generally considered rotamers. – ron Nov 14 '14 at 0:58
• Is it legitimate to refer to cyclobutatetraene and cyclobutadiyne as different compounds, or are they just different resonance structures? Both are just a ring of 4 carbon atoms and no hydrogen. – DavePhD Nov 14 '14 at 15:31
• @PrittBalagopal It fits within the stated "ground rules". – ron Jun 3 '17 at 19:59

How many different organic structures (from the pure theoretical viewpoint) can be drawed with only 4 (exact) carbon atoms and with/without hydrogen?

We could make strict rules like each carbon has exactly 4 bonds and get a specific answer, but this is not reality. There can be lone pair electrons and unpaired electrons. The octet rule is not stictly followed.

$\ce {C_4}$ actually has been observed and is linear.

:C=C=C=C:

$\ce {C_4}$ has been the subject of numerous theoretical and experimetal papers because of its possible occurrence in nebulae. It has been debated whether a singlet linear, triplet linear or rhombic (kite shape) state is the lowest energy state. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0009261400005765

Neither the linear nor rhombic states follow the naive rules.

Linear $\ce{C_4H}$ has been observed both in the lab and outer space.

In fact according to the University of Kohn lists Molecules in Space, linear $\ce{C_4H}$ is one of only 61 molecules and molecular ions found in extragalactic space and of only 190 found in the interstellar medium or circumstellar shells as of 2016.

For $\ce{C_4H_2}$ linear butadiyne in known. Cyclobutatriene, cyclobutenyne and tetrahedrene have been ruled out theoretically as not represtenting any actual potential energy local minimum, while similar to $\ce {C_4}$, structures having lone pair or unpaired electrons and not following the octet rule (such as carbenes) have been calculated to represent actual minima. See the following references for theoretical cyclic $\ce{C_4H_2}$ structures:

http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/jcc.540020211/pdf

http://pubs.acs.org/doi/pdf/10.1021/jo060698k

http://pubs.acs.org/doi/pdf/10.1021/jo000941u

In outer space, not only has the usual HCCCCH isomer been found but also $\ce{H2CCCC}$

• Yes, I was wondering as well how many of these structures are in fact known from the experimental side... – riemannium Nov 15 '14 at 19:34