Two organic chemistry textbooks I've read (by Bruice and by Tandon) say:

Esters are more acidic than ketones, because the resonance between the two oxygen atoms gives less opportunity for the delocalization of the electron pair on the alpha carbon in esters contrary to what happens in ketones.

But, in esters, when the resonance happens between the two oxygen atoms, the oxygen atom gains a positive charge which is highly unstable, given that oxygen is highly electronegative. So, shouldn’t the order of acidity be the other way round?


So, shouldn’t the order be the other way round?

Yes, it is the other way around. Ketones (pKa ~ 20) are more acidic than esters (pKa ~ 25). The figure below shows the resonance structures for the enolate anion of a ketone and an ester. Resonance structures II and IV stabilize the enolate anion in the ketone and ester respectively. In the ester, there is an additional resonance structure, V. Through resonance structure V, the alkoxy group in the ester donates electrons to the carbonyl. This movement of electron density towards the carbonyl will tend to destabilize the formation of any negative charge on the carbon attached on the other side of the carbonyl (electrostatic repulsion). This reduces the likelihood of the formation of an enolate anion on that carbon. Therefore, in the ester, to whatever extent structure V contributes, structure IV will contribute somewhat less. Hence, the ester enolate anion resonance structure IV plays a smaller role and the enolate anion is less stabilized in the ester compared to the ketone. Consequently, the ester is less acidic than the ketone.

enter image description here

  • 5
    $\begingroup$ Excellent answer (as usual). Just a small addendum: Both cases can be considered a Y aromatic system if you include hyperconjugation from the R groups. Then it is obvious, that in the ester case the $\pi$-system is better delocalised (larger), hence leads to a more stable configuration. $\endgroup$ – Martin - マーチン Oct 31 '14 at 1:50
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ So this is an example of the exception of the rule that the greater the number of resonance structures the greater the stability. We should take account the stability (energy) of each resonance structure. $\endgroup$ – ado sar Aug 21 '20 at 15:50
  • $\begingroup$ Is it really an exception? The ester is indeed more delocalised, but not by much. So when one has to deal with similar conjugated systems, analysing the resonance structures and comparing them face-to-face will reveal the answer. $\endgroup$ – TheRelentlessNucleophile Apr 4 at 5:24

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.