My inclination is that you are correct and the reaction proceeds by an SN2 reaction. Secondary alkyl halides can react by either an SN1 or SN2 mechanism, so the other reaction conditions are important to make a decision of the predominant pathway. Since cyanide is a strong nucleophile (and often utilized as the prototypical SN2 nucleophile), that suggests that the reaction should go through an SN2 pathway. One other piece of information that we don't have is the solvent. If this is run in a protic solvent, that could tip the pathway toward SN1, while polar aprotic will favor SN2. I also would not be surprised if both pathways are operating.
It is true that the aromatic ring will stabilize a carbocation at the benzylic position, but it will also stabilize the transition state of the SN2 reaction.
A brief literature search has revealed less insight than I expected. The closest result I have been able to find is that an optically active benzylic bromide treated with trimethylsilyl cyanide in acetonitrile (polar aprotic solvent) does give an optically active benzylic cyanide, suggesting SN2.
DOI: 10.1055/s-0030-1260187