I have a conceptual physical chemistry question here.

A thermos bottle containing milk is shaken vigorously. Consider the milk as the system. Will the temperature rise as a result of the shaking?

My answer to this is yes, but I'm having trouble finding an equation that explains this result.

The best i have is the molecular kinetic energy formula that $$\mathrm{ke_{avg}= \frac{1}{2}mv^2=\frac{3}{2}kT}$$ So a change in kinetic energy is $$ \mathrm{\Delta ke = \frac{3}{2} k \Delta T}$$

Is this the right approach?


A conceptual approach might work better, since the shaking system is not going to convert mechanical energy into thermal energy as neatly as something like Joule's Paddle Wheel. As the bottle is shaken, the liquid in it is swirled around into more or less randomly oriented vortices. These cancel one another out and slow to rest via friction with their container, and the energy they contained has to go somewhere. As you wrote, it winds up increasing the average velocity, and thereby temperature, of the particles in the milk.

This basic mechanical to thermal energy conversion is the source of the conversion factor from joules to calories. Joules are used to measure mechanical energy and calories were used to measure thermal energy. It was the paddle wheel experiment I linked above that first related the two to one another.

The challenge presented by trying to relate the work done on the bottle of milk to the thermal energy that winds up going into the milk is less mathematical than practical. On any given shake we would first put energy into the bottle (move it upward, let's say) then take energy back out (slow it to a stop) before putting energy back into the bottle (moving back downward) and taking energy out again (slowing to a stop a second time.) This repeats until we get tired of shaking, and if we measured the difference in all of the energy inputs and outputs that ought to equal the thermal energy added to the milk, but actually doing that for real would be a pain.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.