5
$\begingroup$

D-tartaric acid

Why is the isomer of tartaric acid above labelled as ᴅ and (−)?

  1. it rotates plane-polarized light clockwise
  2. it rotates plane-polarized light anticlockwise
  3. it is an equimolar mixture of the enantiomorphs
  4. its configuration is related to that of ᴅ-glyceraldehyde

If I am not wrong, the ᴅ in ᴅ-glyceraldehyde refers to (+)-glyceraldehyde, and likewise ʟ-glyceraldehyde is (−)-glyceraldehyde. The (+) and (−) labels indicate that these isomers are dextrorotatory and levorotatory, respectively.

So in ᴅ-(−)-tartaric acid, what does the ᴅ mean, if not dextro, and what does the (−) mean, if not levo (the minus sign indicating anticlockwise rotation of plane-polarized light)? How can one molecule be both?

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Wikipedia has a useful section on this topic. $\endgroup$ – Freddy Sep 30 '14 at 9:20
7
$\begingroup$

As far as I remember, small d always means the same as (+), not small cap ᴅ. So, a dextrorotatory compound is prefixed with either (+) or d while a levorotatory compound is prefixed with either (−) or l.

Small caps ᴅ and ʟ prefixes have different meaning: if an enantiomer can in principle be synthesized from naturally occurring (+)-glyceraldehyde without affecting its configuration, it is considered the ᴅ-form. Otherwise, it is considered the the ʟ-form. And, say, the ᴅ-form of a molecule is not necessarily a dextrorotatory one.

So, the answers to your question are options 2 (the (−) sign indicates that it rotates plane-polarized light anticlockwise), and option 4 (the ᴅ label indicates that it is related to ᴅ-glyceraldehyde).

$\endgroup$
5
$\begingroup$

Dextrorotatory and levorotatory are a set of two terms that designate the direction polarised light is rotated to by a specific compound. Chiral compounds can be identified as being chiral due to their optical activity only. The optical activity is a physically measurable parameter, determined in polarimeters and calculated to a specific optical activity by dividing by concentration and length of the cuvette. Rotation to the right is indicated by a $(+)$ sign, while rotation to the left is indicated by a $(-)$.

The names dextro- and levorotatory derive from the Latin words dexter (right, as in right hand) and laevus (left, as in left hand).


The D/L-nomenclature is entirely different from the above. While the prefixes D and L also derive from the same Latin words, they are used in a different way. They key to D/L-nomenclature is a Fischer projection. If a chiral molecule is drawn in such a (linear) projection, and the group of the highest priority (typically the group with the highest oxidation state) is at the top, a compound is defined as L if the non-hydrogen atom on the lowest asymmetric carbon of the chain points to the left. Likewise, if it points to the right, a compound is termed D.

D-Glyceraldehyde L-Tartaric acid D-Tartaric acid
From left to right: D-Glyceraldehyde, L-tartaric acid, D-tartaric acid.


It is very important to know that there is no connection between D/L and the direction of rotation of polarised light! Likewise, one cannot deduce the direction of optical activity from knowing whether a compound is (R) or (S). D/L and (R)/(S) can be determined on paper or via crystal structures while $(+)/(-)$ can only be determined experimentally in a polarimeter or similar experiments.

That D-glyceraldehyde is dextrorotatory is a mere (but maybe lucky) coincidence.


Therefore, the correct answers to your given question are (2) (it rotates to the left; $(-)$) and (4) (it relates back to D-Glyceraldehyde).

$\endgroup$

protected by orthocresol Sep 5 '17 at 13:56

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.