3
$\begingroup$

To exterminate a coackroach infestation, I bought solid boric acid (in powder form). Rather than awaiting the cockroaches' encounter with the boric acid, I thought about spraying boric acid onto affected areas or cockroaches. I only took high school chemistry, but remembered solubility so checked its solubility in water. I then compared it with the solubility of other compounds, to see if this were an effective idea:

Boric acid: At 100 Celsius, 27.53 g/100 g of water.

Sodium chloride: At 100 Celsius, 38.99 g/100 g of water.

This looks fine, so I poured boiling water into a bottle with the boric acid powder. I shook it and saw the boric acid dissolve. Yet two weeks later, the boric acid seems to have reversed dissolution. Now, it's separated from the water and sits at the bottom of the water.

Can substances do this? What should I do now? I'd need a pot to boil the mixture over the stove. But then, in the interest of health and safety, I couldn't use this pot anymore, so don't want to sacrifice one.

Update: With thanks to and in view of the instructive answers, would it help to refill the bottle, to benefit from the low solubility of boric acid at room temperature? There's only around 10% of water left, with the boric acid sitting at the bottom.

$\endgroup$
  • 5
    $\begingroup$ Never pour water into acid, either solid or liquid. Heat is released when acids dissolve in water. This could lead to local boiling and an acid splashing into your face. $\endgroup$ – Tomáš Zato Sep 21 '14 at 22:05
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ You could put the bottle (of boric acid and water) into a pot of water to heat it up. But why bother. You can use the spray as is and when the liquid is mostly gone, you can add more water, mix it every five minutes for about an hour and you can use that to spray the cockroaches. $\endgroup$ – LDC3 Sep 21 '14 at 22:18
10
$\begingroup$

I think what you forgot is that the solubility of boric acid (or sodium chloride.. or most solids) is lower at room temperature.

So when you dissolved the boric acid in boiling water, there's no problem at first. As it cooled, you will have a supersaturated solution until eventually the boric acid will recrystallize or crash out.

I'd create a new mixture using room temperature water and add only a small amount of boric acid (as mentioned by @K_P, about 5g / 100 mL of water). Let it dissolve slowly while you mix.

Then if you spray, you shouldn't leave large amounts of boric acid around.

Updated Answer

Yes, if there's only ~10% water, you will want to add more (room temperature) water. This will dissolve more boric acid. Stir/shake to dissolve as much as possible, wait a bit and then you can spray again.

As mentioned, you don't want to add water to a hot acid. In this case, adding more room temperature water to a room temperature acid will probably produce heat, but add slowly and carefully.

$\endgroup$
5
$\begingroup$

Usually, when you want to create saturated solution the approach is following:

  1. You heat the water (does not need to boil though)
  2. You dissolve as much solid substance as possible
  3. Let the water cool down
  4. Pour the water through filter to filter out any recrystallised solid compound

The amount you can dissolve is the amount that can be ever dissolved. If the temperature decreases, some of the dissolved compound will recrystallize.

$\endgroup$
2
$\begingroup$

Looking at your link, the solubility of boric acid at room temperature is around 5g / 100g of water. You can either heat it to boiling point to redissolve or you can filter it and this way you will get a 5g / 100g solution of boric acid that you can still use and also recover solid boric acid. You may need to experiment with different DIY filtering devices depending on the particle size of your precipitated boric acid but I guess you made some nice crystals that shouldn't be very hard to filter.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.