I was given just this statement at face value, but I think it refers to nucleophilic reactions where the carbonyl is the electrophile.

From what I understand, the $\ce{-OR}$ in ester is more electron donating inductively than the $\ce{-OH}$ in $\ce{-COOH}$ (due to the alkyl groups in $\ce{-OR}$). So this should make the carbonyl carbon less positive, making it a weaker electrophile, making it less reactive no?

The resources I read say that it's because the $\ce{-OR}$ is a better leaving group than $\ce{-OH}$. But alkoxide ($\ce{RO-}$) is a stronger base than hydroxide ($\ce{OH-}$), so why would it leave first?


1 Answer 1


Remember that a carboxylic acid is an ACID. It donates a proton, forming an anion and will protonate anionic and basic nucleophiles rendering them non-nucleophilic. If there is an excess of the nucleophile, this means that it is attempting to attack a species that is negatively charged; this is not a favourable interaction. Should it succeed the leaving group is not -OH it is O-


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.