Rare Earth's up to z=62 (Samarium) are often called 'light' rare Earths, while z=63 (Europium) and beyond are sometimes referred to as 'heavy' ones...

Why the distinction, though?

Never have I come across (or heard about) a reason for ?arbitrarily? dividing them this way....

Are the light ones often found separately from the heavier ones?

Are they processed and separated differently?

Since they are rarely found in this country, and almost never processed here, neither I nor anyone else I've met in person has worked with them.... Maybe that will change with Round Top Mountain in Texas....


Though scandium and yttrium have lower atomic mass, they fall in the category of HREEs. The classification seems to have something to do with the formation of REE ores. Here is an extract of Wikipedia describing this phenomenon.

REE are chemically very similar and have always been difficult to separate, but a gradual decrease in ionic radius from LREE to HREE, called lanthanide contraction, can produce a broad separation between light and heavy REE. The larger ionic radii of LREE make them generally more incompatible than HREE in rock-forming minerals, and will partition more strongly into a melt phase, while HREE may prefer to remain in the crystalline residue, particularly if it contains HREE-compatible minerals like garnet. The result is that all magma formed from partial melting will always have greater concentrations of LREE than HREE, and individual minerals may be dominated by either HREE or LREE, depending on which range of ionic radii best fits the crystal lattice.

The original reference is included below:


Winter, John D. (2010). Principles of igneous and metamorphic petrology (2nd ed.). New York: Prentice Hall. ISBN 9780321592576. OCLC 262694332.

Jébrak, Michel; Marcoux, Eric; Laithier, Michelle; Skipwith, Patrick (2014). Geology of mineral resources (2nd ed.). St. John's, NL: Geological Association of Canada.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.