2
$\begingroup$

It would make sense that when the benzene rings are fused they keep their pi bonds and form a polycyclic alkyne. However this is not the case.

My hypothesis is that because monocyclic alkynes at 8C or above are stable polycyclic alkynes would be even more stable and more stable with smaller rings than monocyclic alkynes.

However with 7 benzene rings fused in a hexagonal tiling type fashion the center ring has all single bonds like cyclohexane.

Why is it that fusing benzene or really any aromatic compound does not form polycyclic alkynes?

enter image description here

A resonance structure of this would be a polycyclic alkyne along with just the regular pi bond delocalization.

Bicyclo[4.4.0]deca-1,3,6,8,tetraene-4-yne is what I am thinking about. I am moving just the pi bonds in the resonance structure to get this. I am not moving actual carbon nuclei.

I can't find a picture of this but hopefully from the name you can figure it out.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ To have an alkyne in a ring, we would need to have two adjacent carbons that don't have a C-H bond. In naphthalene, if you break the central 9, 10 bond and preserve the outer ring, you don't have two such adjacent carbons without C-H bonds. Also, in resonance structures we can't move nuclei. Could you include a picture of the alkyne you had in mind? $\endgroup$ – ron Jul 26 '14 at 15:10
  • $\begingroup$ See my edit and tell me where to but the 4 double and 1 triple bond. $\endgroup$ – ron Jul 26 '14 at 16:10
4
$\begingroup$

If a polycyclic aromatic compound were to ring open, an allene would be the initial, symmetry-allowed, ring-opened product instead of an alkyne.

enter image description here

I've built a Dreiding model of the bis-allene product derived from naphthalene and it does not appear to be particularly strained. I suspect the reason we do not see this process occurring is because the starting polycyclic aromatic is highly (resonance) stabilized, whereas the bis-allene product, while not strained, has no resonance stabilization due to the lack of pi-overlap in the cyclic structure due to the orthogonality imposed by the allene units. In other words, the activation energy would be too high and the reaction would not proceed. However, if we were to pass naphthalene through a tube furnace at very high temperature (this has been done), it would be interesting to see if any of the resultant products could be explained on the basis of the bis-allene intermediate.

EDIT Here's the bicyco[4.4.0] skeleton. Using these numbers tell me where you want the 4 double and 1 triple bond.

enter image description here

Ah, so this (the structure on the right) is what you mean! There are 2 issues with it

  1. In this structure the bridgehead carbons each have 5 bonds, but carbon can only have 4 bonds (at least in compounds such as these) making this an unrealistic structure.
  2. This structure has 12 pi electrons, whereas the starting naphthalene only had 10. Resonance structures involve the movement of electrons, there is no way to go from 10 pi electrons to 12 pi electrons while keeping all of the sigma bonds intact, so this is not a resonance structure for naphthalene.
$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ but a possible resonance structure of this is a polycyclic alkyne which would result in a monocyclic alkyne in the ring opening. Isn't it that if something is stable with 1 ring that multiple makes it even more stable and so polycyclic alkynes are more stable than monocyclic ones? $\endgroup$ – Caters Jul 26 '14 at 12:45
  • $\begingroup$ If so than I still don't understand why aromaticity is more important in polycyclic compounds than stability of possible resonance structures(including ones with triple bonds) $\endgroup$ – Caters Jul 26 '14 at 12:47
  • $\begingroup$ It would help me understand if you could edit your question and include a picture. $\endgroup$ – ron Jul 26 '14 at 13:44
  • $\begingroup$ I want the triple bond between the bridgehead carbons and the double bonds at C's 2,4,7,and 9. This is what I thought you could get as a resonance structure of naphthalene without moving any carbon nuclei. $\endgroup$ – Caters Jul 26 '14 at 16:16
5
$\begingroup$

The ideal bond angles for alkynes are $180^{\circ}$, which is necessary for optimal overlap of atomic orbitals combining to produce mutually perpendicular $\pi$-type molecular orbitals. Any significant deviation from this is normally inherently destabilizing. Rings, by the very nature of their geometry, often incur additional strain due to their conformational inflexibility and possible demands for non-ideal bond angles (relative to acyclic molecules, that is). Introducing $\pi$-bonds into rings can potentially compound this problem, since they force at least local planarity and shorter bond lengths. These factors all contribute to the immense instability of cyclic alkynes in general.

When you mention stable cycloalkynes, keep in mind that stability is a relative term in this context. While those with a sufficient number of carbons can be produced and isolated under specific experimental conditions, they are not thermodynamically stable relative to their open-chain equivalents, or to most of their various possible structural isomers. In some cases, they can, however, be made kinetically stable by the addition of flanking $\alpha$-substituents which inhibit reaction by their steric bulk1.

Syntheses of cycloalkynes below cyclooctyne are often elaborate, and frequently proceed through extremely reactive intermediates that decompose by specific reaction pathways so as to carefully avoid other products. Benzene (and the various polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, for that matter), on the other hand, is an extremely stable molecule which participates in quite a limited collection of reactions. Whatever particular reaction you're suggesting would almost certainly be hugely uphill in energy (i.e., yields a significantly less stable product), and hence very thermodynamically disfavored; it would also certainly have immense kinetic barriers as well (since any such reaction pathway implies at least temporary loss of aromaticity in the transition state[s] and intermediate[s]).

Relevant reading might include Dehydrobenzene and Cycloalkynes by Reinhard W. Hoffmann. There is extensive discussion of the reactivity of cycloalkynes, and numerous examples of spontaneous dimerizations, isomerizations, etc. Evidently, isomerizations to cycloallenes and cyclobutadiene dimers are common, which is a profound testament to the instability of cycloalkynes.

1. For example, 3,3,7,7-tetramethylcycloheptyne, a good description of which (and synthetic scheme for) is given in Strained Hydrocarbons by Dodziuk.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.