3
$\begingroup$

As a non chemist I have read in the Wikipedia article Curcumin that:

Curcumin becomes bright red when it interacts electrostatically with phospholipid film.

This text appeared without source under this image in the article:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curcumin#/media/File:Curcumin_thin_lipid_film.jpg

As an amateur of cooking Indian dishes (which often have bright red "Tandoori" color):

Is there a way to create natural Red food coloring from Turmeric in the house kitchen?

That is to ask; what edible supermarket products contain phospholipid films and how should I use at least one together with Turmeric (fresh-grinned or dry-powdery) to get a bright red solution?


Update

I should note that I didn't intend to ask this question as a "how to make Tandoori colored seasoning paste" question;

About six years ago, I was told by the owner of a large Indian restaurant in Israel, what is the secret (or at least one of the secrets) and the following seems to be that secret from what I understood then and did and replicated several times:

1) Take about 500 gram of dried Kashmiri peppers; clean them from pedicel, placenta and seeds.

2) Put the dried Kashmiri peppers in a metal pan and pour boiled water upon them.

3) Let the dried Kashmiri pepper boil and cool ("water-marinate") about 3-6 hours but don't cook them. Mere boiling, without cooking, enhances pigmentation but doesn't destroy some pigments as in cooking.

4) Remove the water and let the peppers dry.

5) Grind the processed peppers into a paste with a bit of water and cooking oil and add a tablespoon of that paste as a basis for any Tandoori paste you are making (along with salt, lemon, garlic, ginger and possibly other spices).

$\endgroup$
  • 6
    $\begingroup$ Turmeric turns distinctly red at a pH above ~7.8 (we had this experiment in school). Considering that you're cooking tandoori, you would probably use salt and lemon in the seasoning, which would cause the medium to be acidic and revert turmeric into its natural yellow colour. $\endgroup$ – Aniruddha Deb Feb 16 at 12:22
  • $\begingroup$ @AniruddhaDeb in great plea ; please publish this in an answer such as "adding on what Dr. Pippik said"; as you probably know, comments might get deleted with time from various reasons, and yet this is very important. If you choose to do so --- please say if potassium would be a seasoning alternative to salt to prevent yellowization. $\endgroup$ – user61828 Feb 23 at 8:46
  • $\begingroup$ Alright will do! Im in the middle of exams so I'm a bit squeezed on time but I'll try to write an answer tomorrow $\endgroup$ – Aniruddha Deb Feb 23 at 17:12
  • $\begingroup$ @AniruddhaDeb if you still have the will (and hopefully if you have spare time), about yesterday the question was reopened and you are now available to publish an answer; kindly, $\endgroup$ – user61828 Mar 28 at 4:44
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Yep I'm working on an answer right now. Some practical stuff is involved (and I want to take pictures) So I'll post in around a day from now. $\endgroup$ – Aniruddha Deb Mar 28 at 6:47
4
$\begingroup$

Curcumin(the active ingredient in Turmeric) can turn red in two ways: Either by acting as an acid-base indicator or by forming a complex with a phospholipid film, as you stated.

Colour change due to Acid-Base action

The curcumin molecule is a tribasic acid in basic solution, where it exists as its enol tautomer. The loss of one or more protons from the phenolic hydroxyl groups convert the benzene rings into their quinonoid form, which have a larger absorption/emission wavelength than the benzenoid form, giving a red colour.

This indeed works experimentally: a paper highlighting this can be found here. A simple home experiment would also suffice

The left one is a suspension of turmeric in water; the right one is the same suspension, but with a few drops of soap added to it, which make the medium alkaline and cause the turmeric to turn red. Unfortunately, around my kitchen, I could not find an edible compound basic enough to cause turmeric to change colour. Lime is a possible compound that I could test with but I don't have any foodgrade lime powder lying around. Another issue with using this colouring is that any acidic medium will revert the colour back to yellow: this means that sprinkling lemon as garnishing on your dish would change the colour from an appetizing red to a dull yellow.

Colour change due to Phospholipid complex

A lot of papers have been released on this topic, such as this one and this one. The second paper mentions the following synthesis method to prepare curcumin liposomes (curcumin surrounded by a spherical membrane of phospholipid)

The MFGM phospholipids/soybean lecithin was dispersed in chloroform. Curcumin was dissolved in anhydrous ethanol and thoroughly mixed with the MFGM phospholipids/soybean lecithin dispersion in a 250-mL round-bottomed flask. The mixture solution was evaporated on a rotary evaporator at 35°C, until a thin film was formed on the flask. The film was washed with PBS and completely hydrated for 2 h. After the hydration of thin lipid film with PBS, the lipid dispersion was sonicated for 4 min, and finally the liposomes encapsulated with curcumin were obtained.

For cooking food, this above synthesis method seems unreasonable and overkill. I urge you to experiment with a few methods of forming the red curcumin-phospholipid complex yourself, with soy lecithin/eggs. I would have tried some methods out but I don't have these ingredients at home. see edit.

The advantage of having curcumin in a liposome is that it is much more stable: unlike the acid-base action, curcumin in a liposome remains stable across a wider range of pH's, as shown in this graph. This method does show promise, but as I mentioned, you would have to give this a try yourself.

Other practical solutions

Seasoned Advice would probably give you would get a better answer in this field, but I'll drop in my two cents. Generally, chilli powder is used to provide the red colour to Tandoori. More specifically, Kashmiri chilli powder is specifically used for tandoor preparations, such as tandoori chicken and chicken tikka. This powder is applied as a dressing (in combination with oil, rice flour etc after cooking the food) and during marination (chicken is marinated with curd, red chilli powder and turmeric).

Happy cooking!

References:

  • Kuntal Maiti, Kakali Mukherjee, Arunava Gantait, Bishnu Pada Saha, Pulok K. Mukherjee; Curcumin–phospholipid complex: Preparation, therapeutic evaluation and pharmacokinetic study in rats, International Journal of Pharmaceutics, Volume 330, Issues 1–2,
  • Sam-ang Supharoek, Kraingkrai Ponhong, Watsaka Siriangkhawut, Kate Grudpan; Employing natural reagents from turmeric and lime for acetic acid determination in vinegar sample, Journal of Food and Drug Analysis, Volume 26, Issue 2,
  • Hong-Hao Jin, Qun Lu, Jian-Guo Jiang; Curcumin liposomes prepared with milk fat globule membrane phospholipids and soybean lecithin, Journal of Dairy Science, Volume 99, Issue 3,
  • Research gate: Why does curcumin have a red colour in the alkaline condition
  • Wikipedia: Phospholipids, Curcumin

EDIT: I tried to make a phospholipid complex with turmeric and egg yolks in the kitchen. Around a teaspoon of turmeric was mixed with an equal amount of egg yolk and heated in a water bath: An orangish colour was observed, which was in contrast to the bright yellow of the egg yolk. (I scraped the top layer away which had a larger amount of turmeric to reveal the bottom layer, which had more egg yolk)

enter image description here

A possible conclusion that can be drawn from this experiment is that the complex is indeed forming, but the concentration of phospholipids/curcumin is too small to impart the magnitude of red colour required for food colouring. This pretty much conclusively proves that no easily made derivative of turmeric can be used as red food colouring.

| improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$
3
+200
$\begingroup$

Many foods have high phospholipid content. Eggs and soybean have comparatively high amounts, for example. Phopholipids are essential components of all cell membranes, and are in virtually all living things. They function as emulsifiers, one side of the molecule adhering to water (hydrophilic), and the other to fats (termed lipophilic or hydrophobic).

You can buy food-grade lecitithin, derived from various sources, e.g. sunflower seeds, soy beans, eggs, fish, etc., for about US$7.00/100 g.

So I suggest you to try mixing the turmeric with eggs or soybeans or plain lecithin and to let us know if the color changed to an appealing red! Or, as others stated, use some alkali, such as baking soda, though that certainly would change the taste.

| improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Hello Dr, thank you ; just one question - about using baking soda and turmeric, must it be in an oily solution right? Is there a best oil or group of oils for such solutions (refined/cold-pressed)? $\endgroup$ – user61828 Feb 17 at 3:35
  • $\begingroup$ As stated by Aniruddha Deb, the pH is the cause of the color change. See en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PH_indicator . Read, and learn. $\endgroup$ – DrMoishe Pippik Feb 17 at 18:19
  • $\begingroup$ I assume Dr. Pippik won't be mad if I give the green check mark and 15 rep points to Aniruddha Deb who worked very hard to construct his answer which included direct testing. $\endgroup$ – user61828 Mar 29 at 3:24

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy