2
$\begingroup$

I have been reading about $\ce{Mn}$-catalyzed reaction of sodium percarbonate and water to produce gaseous oxygen in medical emergency situations.

This seems safe due to its reagents and products, however I am wondering if there are other reagents that would be suitable and safe enough to fulfill above use.

I did read about lithium perchlorate being used in so-called oxygen candles and capable of a high ratio of oxygen per weight output, however they hardly seem as safe as the above reaction.

$\endgroup$
1
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ Under what conditions? Safest in an operating theater? Aboard an airliner? To carry in an ambulance? In what quantity or rate? $\endgroup$ Commented Jan 28, 2020 at 2:24

1 Answer 1

1
$\begingroup$

Careful, as sodium percarbonate (basically $\ce{3Na2CO3.2H2O2}$) is usually marketed as a chlorine-free bleach. The latter usually has an additive, TAED, which acts as a key activator. See, for example, Wikipedia on OxiClean, where not even listed on the label is TetraAcetylEthyleneDiamine, which is apparently commonly employed as a bleach activator in many laundry products, see this, for example.

TAED reacts with H2O2 in alkaline conditions (referred to as perhydrolysis) creating, in part, Peracetic Acid. The latter PAA is actually preferred over sluggish H2O2 for bleaching. In other words, it is not the H2O2 as the active bleaching agent, but PAA created in situ.

So, other than possibly misleadingly implying that eco-friendly hydrogen peroxide is the active agent, it is, in reality, PAA, a probematic compound with associated health concerns (see Marquand, E. C.; et al. , 2007. "Asthma Caused by Peracetic Acid-Hydrogen Peroxide Mixture". J. Occup. Health. 49 (2): 155–158.). Here is an MSDS on an actual PAA mix, ( 76-61% water, PAA 20-35%, 3% Acetic acid and 1% H2O2), which is far from friendly but does eventually totally decompose into harmless O2, CO2, H2O,...

As such, anyone using a commercial percarbonate product should at least be aware of potential safety issues that one may likely be employing a Peracetic acid mix.

Note, there is an indicator that you do not have pure sodium percarbonate. It is the presence of some dire warning labels.

$\endgroup$

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.