# Why does the reaction of the primary alcohol cyclopentylmethanol with hydrogen bromide follow SN1 mechanism?

Example 2: Identify all the products formed in the following reaction and indicate the major product.

Solution: Three products will be formed in the given reaction as shown below:

In this reaction the primary alcohol undergoes SN1 mechanism by forming a carbocation and then undergoing ring expansion, but primary alcohols prefer SN2 mechanism. So why is this primary alcohol undergoing SN1 mechanism?

• The Sn1 mechanism should be considered relatively unreasonable here. You might consider a Sn1-like mechanism instead where ring expansion is the thing that displaces water, i.e., the C-C bond is the nucleophile. – Zhe Apr 16 '19 at 0:49
• But the carbocation is formed in Sn1 mechanism and ring expansion can only take place if carbocation is formed,also in this reaction the product formed by Sn1 mechamism is major product – saurya yadav Apr 16 '19 at 6:11
• "ring expansion can only take place if carbocation is formed" That is incorrect. The ring expansion could displace the leaving group. – Zhe Apr 16 '19 at 13:24
• The bottom line here is the the provide solution is wrong. – Zhe Apr 16 '19 at 13:25
• Is the given answer to the question regarding major product 1-bromo cyclohexane? – J_B892 Sep 13 '19 at 8:05

The ring-expansion product could be rationalized by a concerted 1,2-alkyl shift displacing $$\ce{OH2^+}$$ without violating first-principles.