A problem I was recently working on poses the following scenario:

A student realizes that protonation of an alcohol makes the -OH into a better leaving group. Therefore, he suggested the following reaction between 1-propanol, sulfuric acid, and trimethylamine. However, this process does not yield the product predicted here. Why not?

enter image description here

The only reason I can think of deals with the leaving group, which I usually only see in tertiary alcohols/SN1 reactions. Therefore, I supppose that since the reaction proceeds via an SN1 mechanism, the carbocation formed in this case (which is primary) would not form at an appreciable rate --> reaction would not proceed to form product predicted.

Is this line of reasoning correct or is there a better reason why the predicted reaction does not occur? Any ideas will be highly appreciated.


closed as off-topic by Mithoron, A.K., Ethiopius, Jon Custer, Todd Minehardt Mar 7 at 23:32

This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:

If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • $\begingroup$ @AdvilSell The diagrams were provided in the question. I am not sure what the question makers used to make the diagrams. $\endgroup$ – Ethiopius Mar 7 at 18:29

Here the reason is not $S_N1$. In fact the $S_N1$ mechanism is quite difficult to observe with $1$-propanol. The main problem is the sulfuric acid, which not only protonates the alcohol but also protonates the trimethylamine, which is a strong base also. Therefore, being protonated, its nucleophilicity is greatly diminished and the reaction can't occur. The protonation and consequent loss of nucleophilicity of trimethylamine is the main reason.


Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.