I understand the concept of an equilibrium buffer solution, however I am a bit hung on how creating it doesn't shift the weak acid equilibrium.

$$\ce{CH3COOH + H2O <=> CH3COO- + H3O+}$$ $$ K_\mathrm{eq} = 1.8 \times 10^{-5}$$

If I add in equimolar amounts of $\ce{CH3COO-}$ (from a salt) to the acid, why wouldn't that just push equilibrium to the left, creating a lot more of the acetic acid, as the $ K_\mathrm{eq}$ is very low, thus shouldn't the concentration of acetate ions be always very low (I can understand that it will increase, but wouldn't it be a minor increase as most of added $\ce{CH3COO-}$ react to form acetic acid)? How would it be possible to have almost the same amount of them?

  • $\begingroup$ It surely would push the equlibrium to the left, but not by much, since there are not many H3O+ in the first place. Also, $10^{-5}$ is not all that low for an equilibrium constant. $\endgroup$ – Ivan Neretin Feb 21 at 8:08
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ The gist with a "pure" acetic acid solution is that only a small fraction of the acetic acid ionizes, since it is a weak acid. So if you make a solution with about equal amounts of acetic acid and acetate, then the solution will buffer either the addition of an acid or a base. $\endgroup$ – MaxW Feb 21 at 8:45
  • $\begingroup$ Is your premise that most of the acetate will form acetic acid that doesn't hold. Note: as you manage special characters here please change the double arrowed sign. $\endgroup$ – Alchimista Feb 21 at 8:57

Let's consider a solution of 100 mM acetic acid to start, and adding sodium acetate to 100 mM (without changing the volume) to make a buffer.

The solution of the weak acid will have a pH of about 2.88. When you add the acetate and make the buffer, the pH will be about 4.75. The corresponding hydronium concentrations are 1.33 mM and 0.018 mM. So when you add the sodium acetate, the equilibrium will be disturbed, and there will be a net reverse reaction, changing the hydronium concentration from 1.33 mM to 0.018 mM, i.e. a change of 1.31 mM. The concentration of acetic acid will change by the same amount, as will the concentration of acetate.

If you calculate the acetic acid concentration before and after adding the acetate, it comes out to 98.7 mM vs. 100 mM. For the acetate, you get 1.33 mM vs 100 mM. (All these calculations are to 2-3 significant figures, and assume ideal diluted solutions, which they are not. However, the rough calculation gives you an idea of the magnitude of the equilibrium shift).

Why does the reaction shift so little?

If we look at the concentration of acetic acid, there seems to be very little shift, even though we added an equimolar amount of acetate. The big change (affecting the reaction quotient Q a lot), is due to the change in hydronium ion concentration (almost two pH units, change by a factor of about 70). That offsets the change in acetate, which was increased from 1.33 mM in the weak acid solution to 100 mM (i.e. also a change by a factor of about 70).

So if some concentrations are much smaller (close to zero) than others, small shifts are sufficient to re-establish equilibrium. If all reactants and products are at similar concentration, they will all change appreciably.

I'm a visual thinker. Is there a way to show this graphically?

Abbreviating the concentration of acetic acid with A, that of acetate with B, and that of hydronium ions with H, we can write the equilibrium constant as:

$$ K_a = \frac{B \times H}{A} $$

Multiplying by A and taking the negative base 10 logarithm, we get:

$$ pKa + pA = pB + pH $$

Now, we can visualize pKa (blue), pA (orange), pB (yellow) and pH (green). When the blue orange pillar has the same height as the green yellow pillar, the system is at equilibrium. Going from left to right, the graphs show adding 100 mM acetic acid to water before and after establishing equilibrium and adding 100 mM acetate to the weak acid solution, again before and after establishing equilibrium.

enter image description here

  • Add acid: Before any acid dissociation, the pH is still neutral and there is no acetate (pB is infinite). The reaction has not reached equilibrium.
  • Pure acid: The pH drops as a small fraction of acid dissociates. Hydronium and acetate concentration are roughly equal.
  • Add base: The concentration of base increases to roughly 100 mM (pB decreases accordingly), and the system is not at equilibrium.
  • Buffer: A very small fraction of acetate reacts with hydronium ions to form acetic acid. Once the pH has risen sufficiently, the system is at equilibrium again.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.