I have used Davies equation to find what I believed was single ion activities and multiplied them on concentrations to define the thermodynamic dissociation constants for any kind of buffer to find equilibrium conditions. Thereby I could reproduce major findings in recent publications which apparently used the activity coefficients obtained from Davies equation in a similar way.

Now I hear from a reviewer:

Unfortunately a misunderstanding about calculated "single-ion activity coefficients" is being promoted in the manuscript.

From a mathematical expression for the mean activity coefficients an expression for single ion activity coefficients can be derived. But these single ion activity coefficients have no physical or thermodynamic meaning.

I know a heated debate on this issue has been going on. Wonder if any proposals for armistice could be suggested.

Perhaps to clarify my predicament, what I understand as single-ion activity are such as the "fs" in $$K_{12}=f_1[H^+]f_2[HA^{2-}]/f_1[H_2A^-]$$ to define the thermodynamic dissociation constant of a buffer.


Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.