My son received a chemistry set for Christmas and we've been working through the experiments over the last few weeks.

One of them involves boiling white vinegar and adding baking soda to produce sodium acetate. After boiling this down it is supposed to result in some crystals forming on the pan. However, after trying it a couple times we haven't been successful in producing any crystals. What are we doing wrong?

Our process is:

  • Add 4 cups of distilled vinegar to a pan. Boil it on the stove.
  • Stir in 4 tablespoons of baking soda. Do this 1 tablespoon at a time, stirring gently to dissolve each spoonful before adding more.
  • Keep at a high boil until it is no longer fizzing.
  • Reduce to a medium heat and boil until only 1 cup remains. This usually takes about an hour.

At this point our booklet says that crystals should be forming around the outside of the pan. However, both times we have no crystals - only a liquid that looks like weak tea.

  • $\begingroup$ You obviously haven't reached the necessary concentration of sodium acetate to cause precipitation. Boil some more, and try letting the solution cool. You want the crystals to form slowly so that you get big crystals. $\endgroup$
    – MaxW
    Jan 7 '19 at 19:56
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ "only a liquid that looks like weak tea" Just to double check: Are you using clear Distilled White vinegar or White Wine vinegar? If you're not using clear distilled white vinegar, you may be introducing other compounds from the vinegar that inhibit crystal growth. (I know you said distilled vinegar in your process, but I've done far, far sillier things, so just double checking the ingredient list.) $\endgroup$
    – Van
    Jan 7 '19 at 21:18
  • $\begingroup$ @Van It's distilled white vinegar. $\endgroup$ Jan 7 '19 at 21:23
  • $\begingroup$ @MaxW I took the latest batch off the heat to cool at room temperature. The result is (for lack of a better word) brown goo. $\endgroup$ Jan 7 '19 at 21:26
  • $\begingroup$ I was going to suggest that you super saturated the system, but that doesn't seem very likely if you have brown goo. You could try to add a single grain of table salt to see if that does anything (I doubt it). $\endgroup$
    – Zhe
    Jan 7 '19 at 21:28

The solubility of sodium acetate is interesting (that means confusing!). Sodium acetate exists in two forms: anhydrous and trihydrate. When compounds exist in two forms like this, the solubilities, given in grams per 100 mL H20, are predictable: the hydrated form is much more soluble, because it is only partially the compound, and the other part is extra water, the solvent.

However, sodium acetate displays a different behavior:

enter image description here


Sometimes different hydration stages of compounds have different temperature ranges of stability and solubility, but the behavior of sodium acetate is unique. The precipitate that forms so impressively upon cooling is probably the trihydrate, because the amount of sodium acetate in solution according to the recipe does not seem (in my quick estimate) to exceed the solubility of the anhydrous compound, and so the solution produced might be metastable. For some length of time. But, we may be able to initiate crystallization by scratching the glass container, or stirring it, or allowing a drop to dry completely to produce some solid, then using that as a seed for the rest of the solution. Or freezing it.

What I have done is to heat some (pure) sodium acetate to form a concentrated solution (calculated to be supersaturated at room temp), then cooled it: no ppt. Then I touched the surface of the solution with my fingertip and BOOM! Crystallization proceeded like a shot, producing a mass of crystals that filled the container and solidified the former liquid mass. (Did I say it was supersaturated?) I was surprised at the mass of crystals compared to the amount of material I had added to the water at the beginning, but did not think about it till now.

It turns out that the solubility curves of trihydrate and anhydrous sodium acetate are quite separated:

enter image description here


The formation of trihydrate at low temperatures must be a difficult process, and the brown goo obtained here might signify some crystallization inhibitor is present. Maybe a slight excess of NaHCO3 or HCH3CO2 is holding things up - you could try adding a drop of the vinegar, or a few grains of NaHCO3 to see if that changed anything. But If you have a glass rod, scratch the side of the glass container - that works almost all the time.


What you are trying to prepare is a "super-saturated" solution. How fast and how much of a substance will dissolve in a solvent often depends on temperature. For example, you can make a lot more sugar dissolve in a glass of hot water than a glass of cold water. A solution is super-saturated when you dissolve the maximum amount of solute at a high temperature then let the solution cool. That solution now has more solvent dissolved in it that it is supposed to at the cooler temperature. Often, this sets things up for crystals to form (the solution expels the overabundance of solvent via crystal-formation). Anyway, I'd try taking what you already have, heating it back up again. Add more of the baking soda if you still have some. If not, don't worry about it. Let the solution simmer longer than the directions call for, then let it cool down slowly. Sometimes crystals take a couple of days to form.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.