Skip to main content
deleted 1 character in body
Source Link
Buck Thorn
  • 22.9k
  • 5
  • 39
  • 91

Yet on a phase diagram sublimation never begins [highlight mine] until well above absolute zero.

At (theoretical) absolute zero substances lack the energy to undergo a phase transition. The structure is a perfect lattice and the only energy is zero-point energy.

In addition, points on phase diagrams represent equilibrium points. A solid in a vacuum is in non-equilibrium. Vapor pressure is a value associated with an equilibrium state without beginning or end.

Only abovewhen T>0 K will molecules have sufficient energy to form a disordered phase or detach from a lattice. A disordered interfacial phase on a solid surface does not represent a minimum free energy state relative to (a perfect) vacuum. Surface molecules with enough energy will tend to detach and escape into a persistent vacuum. Note they will tend to take energy resulting in evaporative cooling. A similar principle is used to generate super-cold atoms, see for instance this Scientific American article:

Further cooling is done by evaporative cooling, by selective removal of the most energetic atoms from the system. The same process cools a cup of coffee when the most energetic molecules escape as steam, thus lowering the average energy and therefore the temperature of the remaining molecules. In a magnetic trap, the most energetic atoms can move farther against the pull of the magnetic forces, and can therefore reach regions with higher magnetic fields than the colder atoms can. At those high magnetic fields, they get into resonance with radio waves or microwaves, which changes the magnetic moment in such a way that the atoms fly away and escape from the trap. Nice animations of the cooling procedure can be found at http://www.colorado.edu/physics/2000/bec/temperature.html [ [ Source: How are temperatures close to absolute zero achieved and measured? Scientific American, Jan 19, 2004 ]

Yet on a phase diagram sublimation never begins [highlight mine] until well above absolute zero.

At (theoretical) absolute zero substances lack the energy to undergo a phase transition. The structure is a perfect lattice and the only energy is zero-point energy.

In addition, points on phase diagrams represent equilibrium points. A solid in a vacuum is in non-equilibrium. Vapor pressure is a value associated with an equilibrium state without beginning or end.

Only above T>0 K will molecules have sufficient energy to form a disordered phase or detach from a lattice. A disordered interfacial phase on a solid surface does not represent a minimum free energy state relative to (a perfect) vacuum. Surface molecules with enough energy will tend to detach and escape into a persistent vacuum. Note they will tend to take energy resulting in evaporative cooling. A similar principle is used to generate super-cold atoms, see for instance this Scientific American article:

Further cooling is done by evaporative cooling, by selective removal of the most energetic atoms from the system. The same process cools a cup of coffee when the most energetic molecules escape as steam, thus lowering the average energy and therefore the temperature of the remaining molecules. In a magnetic trap, the most energetic atoms can move farther against the pull of the magnetic forces, and can therefore reach regions with higher magnetic fields than the colder atoms can. At those high magnetic fields, they get into resonance with radio waves or microwaves, which changes the magnetic moment in such a way that the atoms fly away and escape from the trap. Nice animations of the cooling procedure can be found at http://www.colorado.edu/physics/2000/bec/temperature.html [ [How are temperatures close to absolute zero achieved and measured? Scientific American, Jan 19, 2004 ]

Yet on a phase diagram sublimation never begins [highlight mine] until well above absolute zero.

At (theoretical) absolute zero substances lack the energy to undergo a phase transition. The structure is a perfect lattice and the only energy is zero-point energy.

In addition, points on phase diagrams represent equilibrium points. A solid in a vacuum is in non-equilibrium. Vapor pressure is a value associated with an equilibrium state without beginning or end.

Only when T>0 K will molecules have sufficient energy to form a disordered phase or detach from a lattice. A disordered interfacial phase on a solid surface does not represent a minimum free energy state relative to (a perfect) vacuum. Surface molecules with enough energy will tend to detach and escape into a persistent vacuum. Note they will tend to take energy resulting in evaporative cooling. A similar principle is used to generate super-cold atoms, see for instance this Scientific American article:

Further cooling is done by evaporative cooling, by selective removal of the most energetic atoms from the system. The same process cools a cup of coffee when the most energetic molecules escape as steam, thus lowering the average energy and therefore the temperature of the remaining molecules. In a magnetic trap, the most energetic atoms can move farther against the pull of the magnetic forces, and can therefore reach regions with higher magnetic fields than the colder atoms can. At those high magnetic fields, they get into resonance with radio waves or microwaves, which changes the magnetic moment in such a way that the atoms fly away and escape from the trap. [ Source: How are temperatures close to absolute zero achieved and measured? Scientific American, Jan 19, 2004 ]

added 1131 characters in body
Source Link
Buck Thorn
  • 22.9k
  • 5
  • 39
  • 91

Yet on a phase diagram sublimation never begins [highlight mine] until well above absolute zero.

First, atAt (theoretical) absolute zeroabsolute zero substances lack the energy to undergo a phase transition. The structure is a perfect lattice and the only energy is zero-point energy.

SecondIn addition, points on phase diagrams are in principlerepresent equilibrium points. Placing aA solid in a vacuum creates ais in non-equilibrium state. Vapor pressure is a value associated with an equilibrium state without beginning or end.

Therefore molecules on the surface of a solid must beOnly above 0T>0 K to will molecules have sufficient energy to form a disordered phase or detach from thea lattice. If a vacuum is sustained aboveA disordered interfacial phase on a solid then a liquid willsurface does not berepresent a minimum free energy state andrelative to (a perfect) vacuum. Surface molecules with enough energy will tend to detach and escape into thea persistent vacuum. Note they will tend to take energy resulting in evaporative cooling. A similar principle is used to generate super-cold atoms, see for instance this Scientific American article:

Further cooling is done by evaporative cooling, by selective removal of the most energetic atoms from the system. The same process cools a cup of coffee when the most energetic molecules escape as steam, thus lowering the average energy and therefore the temperature of the remaining molecules. In a magnetic trap, the most energetic atoms can move farther against the pull of the magnetic forces, and can therefore reach regions with higher magnetic fields than the colder atoms can. At those high magnetic fields, they get into resonance with radio waves or microwaves, which changes the magnetic moment in such a way that the atoms fly away and escape from the trap. Nice animations of the cooling procedure can be found at http://www.colorado.edu/physics/2000/bec/temperature.html [ [How are temperatures close to absolute zero achieved and measured? Scientific American, Jan 19, 2004 ]

Yet on a phase diagram sublimation never begins [highlight mine] until well above absolute zero.

First, at (theoretical) absolute zero substances lack the energy to undergo a phase transition. The structure is a perfect lattice and the only energy is zero-point energy.

Second, points on phase diagrams are in principle equilibrium points. Placing a solid in a vacuum creates a non-equilibrium state. Vapor pressure is a value associated with an equilibrium state without beginning or end.

Therefore molecules on the surface of a solid must be above 0 K to have sufficient energy to detach from the lattice. If a vacuum is sustained above a solid then a liquid will not be a minimum free energy state and molecules will tend to escape into the vacuum.

Yet on a phase diagram sublimation never begins [highlight mine] until well above absolute zero.

At (theoretical) absolute zero substances lack the energy to undergo a phase transition. The structure is a perfect lattice and the only energy is zero-point energy.

In addition, points on phase diagrams represent equilibrium points. A solid in a vacuum is in non-equilibrium. Vapor pressure is a value associated with an equilibrium state without beginning or end.

Only above T>0 K will molecules have sufficient energy to form a disordered phase or detach from a lattice. A disordered interfacial phase on a solid surface does not represent a minimum free energy state relative to (a perfect) vacuum. Surface molecules with enough energy will tend to detach and escape into a persistent vacuum. Note they will tend to take energy resulting in evaporative cooling. A similar principle is used to generate super-cold atoms, see for instance this Scientific American article:

Further cooling is done by evaporative cooling, by selective removal of the most energetic atoms from the system. The same process cools a cup of coffee when the most energetic molecules escape as steam, thus lowering the average energy and therefore the temperature of the remaining molecules. In a magnetic trap, the most energetic atoms can move farther against the pull of the magnetic forces, and can therefore reach regions with higher magnetic fields than the colder atoms can. At those high magnetic fields, they get into resonance with radio waves or microwaves, which changes the magnetic moment in such a way that the atoms fly away and escape from the trap. Nice animations of the cooling procedure can be found at http://www.colorado.edu/physics/2000/bec/temperature.html [ [How are temperatures close to absolute zero achieved and measured? Scientific American, Jan 19, 2004 ]

Source Link
Buck Thorn
  • 22.9k
  • 5
  • 39
  • 91

Yet on a phase diagram sublimation never begins [highlight mine] until well above absolute zero.

First, at (theoretical) absolute zero substances lack the energy to undergo a phase transition. The structure is a perfect lattice and the only energy is zero-point energy.

Second, points on phase diagrams are in principle equilibrium points. Placing a solid in a vacuum creates a non-equilibrium state. Vapor pressure is a value associated with an equilibrium state without beginning or end.

Therefore molecules on the surface of a solid must be above 0 K to have sufficient energy to detach from the lattice. If a vacuum is sustained above a solid then a liquid will not be a minimum free energy state and molecules will tend to escape into the vacuum.