Take the 2-minute tour ×
Chemistry Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for scientists, academics, teachers and students. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I was trying to isolate elemental bismuth from pepto bismol (bismuth subsalicylate) using the process seen here but after I added the HCl, instead of getting a pink foamy substance I got a white liquid with some white foam. The only reason I can think of, for why this would happen is that the pepto bismol was expired by a month. After I realized the reaction didn't work, I added a homemade universal indicator (red cabbage -Phenolphthalein- preserved with a little isopropyl alcohol) and started adding sodium hydroxide to neutralise any remaining acid. When I started adding the sodium hydroxide the solution started heating up and then changed color fairly rapidly from pink to a dull grey green which didn't change when I tried adding more acid. Shorty after the color change something started to precipitate out. I filtered off the precipitate and got a clear orange liquid. I then added a little HCl to the orange liquid and something immediately started precipitating out. The remaining liquid then turned clear and smells slightly like mint.

My only guess for what I have made is bismuth hydroxide (the first precipitate) but I have no idea what the second precipitate is. Here are pictures of the final precipitates.

share|improve this question
The initial filtration is purely awful lab technique. You cannot isolate a tiny bit of impure bismuth for less than it costs to buy a lot of very pure bismuth. metalshipper.com/bismuth.html <BR> amazon.com/Bismuth-Ingot-Chunk-99-99-Pure/dp/B001QUVMC8 <BR> rotometals.com/Bismuth-s/4.htm <BR> youtube.com/watch?v=s1CNGMElWfA youtube.com/watch?v=MMEkA2_N6vY <BR> Oh, yeah! –  Uncle Al Mar 17 at 20:33
Can you give more details about your lab procedures? What concentration of HCl did you start with? What about the pepto? Did you use tablets or liquid? Etc. –  solarmist May 17 at 2:07

1 Answer 1

I'm not sure you did do the experiment wrong. I performed this experiment and it closely matched this video which had a light yellow liquid and foam.

Here are my results

After first filtration

I filtered it a couple more times to remove more foam. Then added the aluminum foil.

After aluminum foil

This is what I got at the end before I filtered the liquid out at the end.

In the end I was able to extract 6.2 grams of bismuth powder from 67 tablets of pepto (a bit less than the theoretical ~10 grams I was hoping to get).

share|improve this answer
Also, the wiki page on Bismuth chloride show it is a yellow crystal in dry form. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bismuth_chloride –  solarmist May 19 at 20:04

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.